TORIma Academy Logo TORIma Academy
Werner Heisenberg
Science

Werner Heisenberg

TORIma Academy — Physicist

Werner Heisenberg

Werner Heisenberg

Werner Karl Heisenberg ( ; German: [ˈvɛʁnɐ ˈhaɪzn̩bɛʁk] ; 5 December 1901 – 1 February 1976) was a German theoretical physicist, one of the main pioneers of…

Werner Karl Heisenberg (; German: [ˈvɛʁnɐ ˈhaɪzn̩bɛʁk] ; 5 December 1901 – 1 February 1976) was a prominent German theoretical physicist, recognized as a foundational figure in quantum mechanics and a leading scientist within the German nuclear program during World War II.

Werner Karl Heisenberg (; German: [ˈvɛʁnɐˈhaɪzn̩bɛʁk] ; 5 December 1901 – 1 February 1976) was a German theoretical physicist, one of the main pioneers of the theory of quantum mechanics and a principal scientist in the German nuclear program during World War II.

In 1925, Heisenberg published his seminal Umdeutung paper, which offered a significant reinterpretation of the old quantum theory. Later that year, in collaboration with Max Born and Pascual Jordan, he substantially developed his matrix formulation of quantum mechanics through a series of subsequent publications. He is also renowned for the uncertainty principle, introduced in 1927, and was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1932 for his contributions to the creation of quantum mechanics.

Heisenberg's research extended to the hydrodynamics of turbulent flows, the atomic nucleus, ferromagnetism, cosmic rays, and subatomic particles. He is credited with introducing the concept of wave function collapse. Furthermore, in 1957, he played a pivotal role in the planning of West Germany's inaugural nuclear reactor in Karlsruhe, alongside a research reactor in Munich.

After World War II, Heisenberg assumed the directorship of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physics, which was subsequently renamed the Max Planck Institute for Physics. He held this position until the institute's relocation to Munich in 1958. From 1960 to 1970, he served as Director of the Max Planck Institute for Physics and Astrophysics.

Additionally, Heisenberg held several other significant leadership roles, including President of the German Research Council, Chairman of the Commission for Atomic Physics, Chairman of the Nuclear Physics Working Group, and President of the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation.

Early Life and Academic Background

Formative Years

Werner Karl Heisenberg was born in Würzburg, Germany, to Kaspar Ernst August Heisenberg and Annie Wecklein. His father, a secondary school teacher of classical languages, later became Germany's sole ordentlicher Professor (ordinarius professor) of medieval and modern Greek studies within the national university system.

Heisenberg was raised and lived as a Lutheran Christian. During his late teenage years, he read Plato's Timaeus while hiking in the Bavarian Alps. He recalled engaging in philosophical discussions with peers and instructors regarding the nature of the atom during his scientific education in Munich, Göttingen, and Copenhagen. Heisenberg later affirmed the profound influence of philosophy, particularly Plato, on his intellectual development, stating, "My mind was formed by studying philosophy, Plato and that sort of thing." He further asserted that "Modern physics has definitely decided in favor of Plato. In fact the smallest units of matter are not physical objects in the ordinary sense; they are forms, ideas which can be expressed unambiguously only in mathematical language."

In 1919, Heisenberg joined the Freikorps in Munich, participating in efforts against the Bavarian Soviet Republic, which had been established the previous year. Five decades later, he characterized this period as youthful recreation, akin to "playing cops and robbers and so on; it was nothing serious at all." His responsibilities were limited to "seizing bicycles or typewriters from 'red' administrative buildings" and guarding individuals suspected of being "red" prisoners.

University Education

Between 1920 and 1923, Heisenberg pursued studies in physics and mathematics. He attended the University of Munich, where he was mentored by Arnold Sommerfeld and Wilhelm Wien, and the Georg-August University of Göttingen, studying with Max Born, James Franck, and David Hilbert for mathematics. He completed his doctorate in 1923 at Munich under Sommerfeld's supervision.

In June 1922, Sommerfeld accompanied Heisenberg to Göttingen for the Bohr Festival, recognizing both his student's potential and Heisenberg's keen interest in Niels Bohr's atomic physics theories. During the event, Bohr delivered a series of comprehensive lectures on quantum atomic physics, marking Heisenberg's initial encounter with Bohr, an interaction that profoundly influenced him.

Heisenberg's doctoral thesis, proposed by Sommerfeld, focused on turbulence, specifically examining the stability of laminar flow and the fundamental characteristics of turbulent flow. The stability problem was analyzed using the Orr–Sommerfeld equation, a fourth-order linear differential equation applicable to minor disturbances in laminar flow. He revisited this subject briefly following World War II.

In 1924, while at Göttingen and under the guidance of Born, he completed his habilitation, submitting a Habilitationsschrift (habilitation thesis) on the anomalous Zeeman effect.

During his formative years, Heisenberg participated in and led the Neupfadfinder, a German Scout association integral to the German Youth Movement. In August 1923, Heisenberg, alongside Robert Honsell, arranged an expedition to Finland for a Scout contingent from this Munich-based association.

Personal Life

Heisenberg possessed a strong affinity for classical music and demonstrated proficiency as a pianist, with musical performances constituting a significant aspect of his social engagements. From the late 1920s to the early 1930s, he frequently engaged in musical activities and dancing at the Berlin residence of his student, the aristocrat Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker. During this period, his courtship with Carl's high-school-aged sister, Adelheid, temporarily resulted in his disfavor at their home. Subsequently, his musical interests also facilitated his introduction to his future spouse. In January 1937, Heisenberg encountered Elisabeth Schumacher (1914–1998) at a private musical recital. Elisabeth Schumacher was the daughter of a distinguished Berlin economics professor, and her brother was E. F. Schumacher, the economist renowned for authoring Small Is Beautiful. Heisenberg and Schumacher formalized their union on April 29. In January 1938, they welcomed fraternal twins, Maria and Wolfgang, prompting Wolfgang Pauli to humorously commend Heisenberg on his "pair creation," a playful reference to the elementary particle physics phenomenon of pair production. Over the subsequent twelve years, the couple had five additional children: Barbara, Christine, Jochen, Martin, and Verena. In 1939, Heisenberg acquired a summer residence for his family in Urfeld am Walchensee, located in southern Germany.

Among Heisenberg's progeny, Martin Heisenberg pursued a career as a neurobiologist at the University of Würzburg, while Jochen Heisenberg became a professor of physics at the University of New Hampshire.

Academic Career

Göttingen, Copenhagen, and Leipzig

Between 1924 and 1927, Heisenberg held the position of Privatdozent at Göttingen, a qualification that permitted him to teach and examine autonomously, independent of a professorial chair. From September 17, 1924, to May 1, 1925, Heisenberg conducted research with Niels Bohr, the director of the Institute of Theoretical Physics at the University of Copenhagen, supported by an International Education Board Rockefeller Foundation fellowship. On June 7, following an unsuccessful period of attempting to mitigate a severe hay fever episode with aspirin and cocaine, Heisenberg withdrew to Helgoland, a pollen-free island in the North Sea, to concentrate on quantum mechanics. His groundbreaking paper, titled "Über quantentheoretische Umdeutung kinematischer und mechanischer Beziehungen" (translated as "Quantum theoretical re-interpretation of kinematic and mechanical relations") and also known as the Umdeutung (reinterpretation) paper, was published in September 1925. Upon returning to Göttingen, he collaborated with Max Born and Pascual Jordan over approximately six months to formulate the matrix mechanics approach to quantum mechanics. On May 1, 1926, Heisenberg commenced his role as a university lecturer and assistant to Bohr in Copenhagen. It was in Copenhagen, during 1927, that Heisenberg formulated his uncertainty principle, an endeavor undertaken while exploring the mathematical underpinnings of quantum mechanics. On February 23, Heisenberg communicated his nascent principle in a letter to his colleague, physicist Wolfgang Pauli. Notably, in his published work on the principle, Heisenberg employed the term "Ungenauigkeit" (imprecision) rather than 'uncertainty' to characterize it.

In 1927, Heisenberg received an appointment as ordentlicher Professor (professor ordinarius) of theoretical physics and assumed leadership of the physics department at the University of Leipzig; his inaugural lecture occurred on February 1, 1928. In his initial publication from Leipzig, Heisenberg applied the Pauli exclusion principle to elucidate the phenomenon of ferromagnetism.

At the age of 25, Heisenberg achieved distinction as Germany's youngest full-time professor and assumed the professorial chair of the Institute for Theoretical Physics at the University of Leipzig. His lectures attracted notable physicists, including Edward Teller and Robert Oppenheimer, both of whom subsequently contributed to the United States' Manhattan Project.

During Werner Heisenberg's period at Leipzig, the exceptional caliber of his doctoral students, postgraduate researchers, and research associates was evident from the significant recognition many subsequently achieved. This distinguished group included Erich Bagge, Felix Bloch, Ugo Fano, Siegfried Flügge, William Vermillion Houston, Friedrich Hund, Robert S. Mulliken, Rudolf Peierls, George Placzek, Isidor Isaac Rabi, Fritz Sauter, John C. Slater, Edward Teller, John Hasbrouck van Vleck, Victor Frederick Weisskopf, Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker, Gregor Wentzel, and Clarence Zener.

In early 1929, Heisenberg and Wolfgang Pauli co-authored the initial installment of two seminal papers that established the groundwork for relativistic quantum field theory. Concurrently in 1929, Heisenberg embarked on an extensive lecture tour encompassing China, Japan, India, and the United States. During the spring of that year, he served as a visiting lecturer at the University of Chicago, delivering presentations on quantum mechanics. On August 19, 1929, Heisenberg, accompanied by Paul Dirac, arrived in Tokyo aboard the Graf Zeppelin LZ 127 during its inaugural global circumnavigation. The preceding year, in 1928, British mathematical physicist Paul Dirac had formulated his relativistic wave equation for quantum mechanics, which posited the existence of positive electrons, subsequently termed positrons. By 1932, American physicist Carl David Anderson confirmed the positron's existence, identifying its track in a cloud chamber photograph of cosmic rays. Heisenberg subsequently introduced his theory of the positron in mid-1933. His conceptualizations regarding Dirac's theory and its subsequent elaboration were detailed across two publications. The first, titled "Bemerkungen zur Diracschen Theorie des Positrons" ("Remarks on Dirac's Theory of the Positron"), appeared in 1934, followed by "Folgerungen aus der Diracschen Theorie des Positrons" ("Consequences of Dirac's Theory of the Positron") in 1936. Within these works, Heisenberg pioneered the reinterpretation of the Dirac equation as a "classical" field equation applicable to any point particle possessing spin ħ/2, subject to quantization conditions involving anti-commutators. By reinterpreting it as a quantum field equation precisely describing electrons, Heisenberg effectively equated matter with electromagnetism, both being characterized by relativistic quantum field equations that permitted particle creation and annihilation. Notably, Hermann Weyl had previously articulated this concept in a 1929 correspondence to Albert Einstein.

Matrix Mechanics and the Nobel Prize

Heisenberg's seminal Umdeutung paper, which laid the foundation for modern quantum mechanics, has consistently intrigued both physicists and historians. His methodology presupposes a foundational understanding of Kramers-Heisenberg transition probability calculations. The core innovation, the concept of non-commuting matrices, is substantiated primarily by the exclusion of unobservable quantities. This work introduced the non-commutative multiplication of matrices through physical argumentation, grounded in the correspondence principle, notwithstanding Heisenberg's contemporary unfamiliarity with the formal mathematical theory of matrices. The developmental trajectory leading to these findings has been meticulously reconstructed by MacKinnon, while the intricate calculations have been elucidated by Aitchison and his collaborators.

While in Copenhagen, Heisenberg and Hans Kramers co-authored a significant paper concerning dispersion, specifically the scattering of radiation from atoms when the radiation's wavelength exceeds the atomic dimensions. Their research demonstrated that Kramers' previously successful formula could not be predicated upon Bohr orbits, given that transition frequencies are derived from non-constant energy level spacings. Conversely, the frequencies observed in the Fourier transform of classical sharp series orbits exhibit uniform spacing. Nevertheless, these findings were explicable through a semi-classical virtual state model, wherein incident radiation excites the valence (outer) electron to a transient virtual state, from which it subsequently decays. In a later publication, Heisenberg further illustrated that this virtual oscillator model was also capable of elucidating the polarization of fluorescent radiation.

These dual achievements, coupled with the persistent inability of the Bohr–Sommerfeld model to account for the unresolved issue of the anomalous Zeeman effect, prompted Heisenberg to employ the virtual oscillator model for calculating spectral frequencies. However, the methodology proved excessively complex for direct application to practical scenarios, leading Heisenberg to investigate a more tractable example: the anharmonic oscillator.

The dipole oscillator is conceptualized as a simple harmonic oscillator, comprising a charged particle on a spring, subjected to perturbation by an external force, such as an external charge. The oscillatory motion of this charge can be represented through a Fourier series, corresponding to the oscillator's frequency. Heisenberg addressed the quantum behavior of this system using two distinct methodologies. Initially, he applied the virtual oscillator method, which involved computing the transitions between energy levels induced by the external source.

Subsequently, he resolved the identical problem by considering the anharmonic potential term as a perturbation to the harmonic oscillator, employing the perturbation methods previously developed by himself and Born. Both approaches yielded congruent results for both the first-order and the highly intricate second-order correction terms. This congruence implied the existence of an underlying consistent theoretical framework despite the complexity of the calculations.

Consequently, Heisenberg endeavored to articulate these findings independently of any explicit reliance on the virtual oscillator model. His approach involved substituting the Fourier expansions for spatial coordinates with matrices, specifically those matrices that represented the transition coefficients within the virtual oscillator method. This substitution was justified by invoking Bohr's correspondence principle and Pauli's assertion that quantum mechanics should exclusively address observable quantities.

On July 9, Heisenberg presented this manuscript to Born for review and submission for publication. Upon reviewing the paper, Born identified that its formulation could be transcribed and expanded into the systematic language of matrices, a subject he had studied under Jakob Rosanes at Breslau University. Born, aided by his assistant and former student Pascual Jordan, promptly commenced this transcription and extension. Their resulting paper was submitted for publication and accepted merely 60 days after Heisenberg's initial submission. A subsequent paper, co-authored by all three researchers, was submitted for publication before the year concluded.

Prior to this period, physicists rarely employed matrices, which were predominantly regarded as a domain of pure mathematics. Gustav Mie had incorporated them in a 1912 paper on electrodynamics, and Born had utilized them in his 1921 research on the lattice theory of crystals. However, despite their application in these instances, the algebraic operations of matrices, particularly their multiplication, were not central to the theoretical framework in the same profound way they became in the matrix formulation of quantum mechanics.

In 1928, Albert Einstein nominated Heisenberg, Born, and Jordan for the Nobel Prize in Physics. The announcement of the 1932 Nobel Prize in Physics was postponed until November 1933. At that juncture, it was declared that Heisenberg had been awarded the 1932 Prize "for the creation of quantum mechanics, the application of which has, inter alia, led to the discovery of the allotropic forms of hydrogen."

Interpretation of Quantum Theory

The evolution of quantum mechanics, coupled with its seemingly contradictory implications concerning the nature of "reality," generated significant philosophical ramifications, particularly regarding the true meaning of scientific observations. Unlike Albert Einstein and Louis de Broglie, who adhered to a realist perspective positing that particles possess objectively true momentum and position at all times (even if both quantities were unmeasurable), Heisenberg adopted an anti-realist stance. He contended that direct apprehension of what is "real" lay outside the purview of scientific inquiry. In his publication, The Physicist's Conception of Nature, Heisenberg asserted that, fundamentally, one can only discuss the knowledge (represented by numerical data in tables) that describes aspects of particles, without ever gaining "true" access to the particles themselves.

The behavior of particles can no longer be discussed in isolation from the observational process. Consequently, the mathematical formulations of natural laws within quantum theory pertain not to elementary particles themselves, but rather to humanity's understanding of them. Furthermore, the objective existence of these particles within space and time becomes an unanswerable question. Contemporary exact science, when depicting nature, primarily illustrates our intricate relationships with nature. Science has transitioned from an objective observer to an active participant in the dynamic interaction between humanity and the natural world. The traditional scientific approach of analysis, explanation, and classification has acknowledged its inherent limitations, recognizing that scientific intervention inherently modifies and reshapes the subject under investigation. Thus, the methodological approach and the object of study are inextricably linked.

SS Inquiry

Following James Chadwick's 1932 discovery of the neutron, Heisenberg promptly published the initial paper in a series of three detailing his neutron-proton model of the atomic nucleus. Subsequent to Adolf Hitler's ascent to power in 1933, Heisenberg faced public denunciation in the press, labeled a "White Jew"—a pejorative term for an Aryan perceived to act Jewish. Proponents of Deutsche Physik, also known as German Physics or Aryan Physics, initiated aggressive campaigns against prominent theoretical physicists, including Arnold Sommerfeld and Heisenberg. From the early 1930s, the anti-Semitic and anti-theoretical physics movement, Deutsche Physik, specifically targeted quantum mechanics and the theory of relativity. Within the academic sphere, this movement prioritized political allegiance over intellectual merit, despite being championed by two Nobel Laureates in Physics, Philipp Lenard and Johannes Stark.

Heisenberg's numerous attempts to secure a professorship at various German universities were unsuccessful. His bid to succeed Arnold Sommerfeld was specifically thwarted by the opposition from the Deutsche Physik movement. On April 1, 1935, Arnold Sommerfeld, a distinguished theoretical physicist and Heisenberg's doctoral supervisor at the University of Munich, attained emeritus status. Nevertheless, Sommerfeld retained his position throughout the protracted selection process for his successor, which concluded on December 1, 1939. This extended duration was attributable to significant academic and political disagreements between the Munich Faculty's preferred candidate and those favored by the Reich Education Ministry and the proponents of Deutsche Physik.

In 1935, the Munich Faculty compiled a shortlist of candidates to assume Sommerfeld's position as ordinarius professor of theoretical physics and director of the Institute for Theoretical Physics at the University of Munich. All three nominees were former students of Sommerfeld: Heisenberg, a Nobel laureate in Physics; Peter Debye, who would receive the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1936; and Richard Becker. The Munich Faculty strongly endorsed these candidates, with Heisenberg as their primary selection. Conversely, proponents of Deutsche Physik and factions within the Reich Education Ministry (REM) presented their own slate of candidates, prolonging the dispute for more than four years. Throughout this period, Heisenberg endured severe criticism from Deutsche Physik adherents. A particularly virulent assault appeared in Das Schwarze Korps, the official newspaper of the SS, led by Heinrich Himmler. This publication branded Heisenberg a "White Jew" who ought to be "eliminated." Such threats were gravely concerning, given the widespread violent persecution and imprisonment of Jewish individuals. Heisenberg responded by publishing an editorial and dispatching a letter to Himmler, seeking to resolve the accusations and restore his reputation.

The resolution of the "Heisenberg affair" involved a Himmler formally concluded the matter on July 21, 1938, by dispatching two letters: one to SS Gruppenführer Reinhard Heydrich and another to Heisenberg. In his correspondence with Heydrich, Himmler asserted that Germany could not tolerate the loss or suppression of Heisenberg, recognizing his potential utility in educating future generations of scientists. To Heisenberg, Himmler indicated that the letter was issued based on his family's recommendation and advised Heisenberg to differentiate between the outcomes of professional physics research and the personal or political stances of the scientists involved.

Wilhelm Müller succeeded Sommerfeld at the University of Munich, despite lacking qualifications as a theoretical physicist, having no publications in physics journals, and not being a member of the German Physical Society. His appointment was widely perceived as a travesty and detrimental to the education of theoretical physicists.

The three SS investigators responsible for the inquiry into Heisenberg's activities were all trained in physics, with Heisenberg having even participated in the doctoral examination of one at the Universität Leipzig. Johannes Juilfs was the most influential among them. During their investigation, these individuals became advocates for Heisenberg and his stance against the ideological policies of the Deutsche Physik movement in theoretical physics and academia.

The German Nuclear Weapons Program

Pre-War Physics Research

In mid-1936, Heisenberg introduced his theory of cosmic-ray showers through two published papers, with four subsequent papers appearing over the following two years.

In December 1938, German chemists Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann submitted a manuscript to The Natural Sciences, reporting the detection of barium following the bombardment of uranium with neutrons. Hahn concluded that a bursting of the uranium nucleus had occurred. Simultaneously, Hahn communicated these findings to his colleague Lise Meitner, who had fled to the Netherlands and then Sweden in July of that year. Meitner, along with her nephew Otto Robert Frisch, correctly interpreted Hahn's and Strassmann's results as nuclear fission, a phenomenon Frisch experimentally confirmed on January 13, 1939.

In June and July 1939, Heisenberg traveled to the United States, visiting Samuel Abraham Goudsmit at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor. Despite an invitation to emigrate, Heisenberg declined to remain in the United States. He did not encounter Goudsmit again until six years later, when Goudsmit was serving as the chief scientific advisor for the American Operation Alsos at the conclusion of World War II.

Participation in the Uranverein

The German nuclear weapons program, known as the Uranverein, was formally established on September 1, 1939, coinciding with the commencement of World War II in Europe. The Heereswaffenamt (HWA, Army Ordnance Office) integrated the Reichsforschungsrat (RFR, Reich Research Council) from the Reichserziehungsministerium (REM, Reich Ministry of Education), thereby initiating the official German nuclear energy project under military authority. The project's first meeting occurred on September 16, 1939, in Berlin, organized by Kurt Diebner, an advisor to the HWA. Invited participants included Walther Bothe, Siegfried Flügge, Hans Geiger, Otto Hahn, Paul Harteck, Gerhard Hoffmann, Josef Mattauch, and Georg Stetter. A second meeting, held shortly thereafter, included Heisenberg, Klaus Clusius, Robert Döpel, and Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker. The Kaiser-Wilhelm Institut für Physik (KWIP, Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physics) in Berlin-Dahlem was subsequently placed under HWA authority, with Diebner appointed as administrative director, marking the military's assumption of control over nuclear research. During Diebner's tenure administering the KWIP under the HWA program, considerable personal and professional animosity developed between Diebner and Heisenberg's inner circle, which comprised Karl Wirtz and Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker.

On February 26–28, 1942, the Army Weapons Office convened a scientific conference at the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physics, where Heisenberg delivered a lecture to Reich officials concerning energy acquisition from nuclear fission. Titled "Die theoretischen Grundlagen für die Energiegewinnung aus der Uranspaltung" ("The theoretical basis for energy generation from uranium fission"), this presentation was, as Heisenberg later recounted in a post-World War II letter to Samuel Goudsmit, "adapted to the intelligence level of a Reich Minister." During his address, Heisenberg elucidated the immense energy potential of nuclear fission, specifying that 250 million electron volts could be liberated from the fission of a single atomic nucleus. He emphasized the critical requirement of obtaining pure U-235 to initiate a chain reaction. Heisenberg then explored various methodologies for isolating the pure isotope 235
92U, including uranium enrichment and an alternative layered approach involving normal uranium and a moderator within a specialized machine. He further noted that this machine held practical applications for powering vehicles, ships, and submarines. Heisenberg concluded by underscoring the necessity of financial and material backing from the Army Weapons Office for this scientific undertaking.

Subsequently, a second scientific conference was held, featuring presentations on contemporary physics challenges deemed crucial for national defense and economic stability. Bernhard Rust, the Reich Minister of Science, Education, and National Culture, attended this conference. During the proceedings, Minister Rust resolved to transfer the nuclear project's oversight from the Kaiser Wilhelm Society to the Reich Research Council.

In April 1942, the army relinquished control of the Physics Institute, returning it to the Kaiser Wilhelm Society and appointing Heisenberg as its Director. Peter Debye, the previous director, had departed for the United States on leave after declining German citizenship when the HWA assumed administrative authority over the KWIP. Concurrently, Heisenberg maintained his physics department at the University of Leipzig, where Robert Döpel and his wife Klara Döpel had conducted research for the Uranverein.

On June 4, 1942, Heisenberg was summoned to brief Albert Speer, Germany's Minister of Armaments, on the feasibility of reorienting the Uranverein's research towards nuclear weapons development. During this meeting, Heisenberg informed Speer that constructing a bomb before 1945 was improbable, citing the substantial financial and personnel resources required.

Following the transfer of the Uranverein project to the Reich Research Council, its primary focus shifted to nuclear power production, thereby retaining its kriegswichtig (war-critical) designation and ensuring continued military funding. The nuclear power initiative was structured into key components: uranium and heavy water production, uranium isotope separation, and the Uranmaschine (uranium machine, or nuclear reactor). Subsequently, the project was distributed among several institutes, where individual directors largely dictated research priorities and agendas. The year 1942, when the army ceded control of the German nuclear weapons program, marked the peak of the project in terms of personnel involvement. Approximately 70 scientists were engaged in the program, with about 40 dedicating over half their time to nuclear fission research. Post-1942, the number of scientists involved in applied nuclear fission significantly decreased, as many researchers not affiliated with the primary institutes redirected their efforts to other urgent war-related assignments.

In September 1942, Heisenberg submitted the initial paper of a three-part series concerning the scattering matrix, or S-matrix, within the field of elementary particle physics. The first two installments were published in 1943, with the third appearing in 1944. The S-matrix framework exclusively characterized the states of incident particles in a collision, the states of particles emerging from the collision, and stable bound states, deliberately omitting any reference to intermediate states. This methodological approach mirrored the precedent he established in 1925, which ultimately formed the basis for the matrix formulation of quantum mechanics through the sole reliance on observables.

In February 1943, Heisenberg assumed the Chair of Theoretical Physics at the Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität (now Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin). By April, his election to the Preußische Akademie der Wissenschaften (Prussian Academy of Sciences) received official approval. Concurrently, with the escalation of Allied aerial bombardments in Berlin, he relocated his family to their Urfeld retreat. During the summer, he initiated the relocation of personnel from the Kaiser-Wilhelm Institut für Physik to Hechingen and the adjacent town of Haigerloch, situated at the periphery of the Black Forest, citing similar security concerns. Between October 18 and 26, he undertook a journey to the German-occupied Netherlands. Subsequently, in December 1943, Heisenberg visited German-occupied Poland.

Between January 24 and February 4, 1944, Heisenberg journeyed to occupied Copenhagen, following the German army's confiscation of Bohr's Institute of Theoretical Physics. A brief return Later, in December, Heisenberg delivered a lecture in neutral Switzerland. The United States Office of Strategic Services dispatched agent Moe Berg to attend this lecture, equipped with a pistol and explicit instructions to assassinate Heisenberg should his presentation suggest Germany was nearing the development of an atomic bomb.

By January 1945, Heisenberg and the majority of his remaining staff had relocated from the Kaiser-Wilhelm Institut für Physik to the facilities situated within the Black Forest region.

Post-World War II Period

1945: The Alsos Mission

The Alsos Mission constituted an Allied initiative designed to ascertain the existence of a German atomic bomb program and to appropriate German atomic-related infrastructure, research, material assets, and scientific expertise for the strategic advantage of the United States. Operatives typically advanced into territories recently secured by Allied military forces, though on occasion, they conducted operations within areas still under German control. Berlin had previously served as a hub for numerous German scientific research facilities. In the concluding years of the conflict, many of these facilities were dispersed to alternative locations to mitigate casualties and equipment losses. The Kaiser-Wilhelm-Institut für Physik (KWIP, Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physics) had sustained bombing damage, necessitating its relocation primarily in 1943 and 1944 to Hechingen and the adjacent town of Haigerloch, situated at the Black Forest's periphery, an area subsequently incorporated into the French occupation zone. This strategic positioning enabled the American task force of the Alsos Mission to apprehend a significant number of German scientists involved in nuclear research.

By March 30, the Alsos Mission arrived in Heidelberg, leading to the apprehension of prominent scientists such as Walther Bothe, Richard Kuhn, Philipp Lenard, and Wolfgang Gentner. Interrogations subsequently disclosed that Otto Hahn was located at his laboratory in Tailfingen, while Heisenberg and Max von Laue were at Heisenberg's laboratory in Hechingen, and that the experimental natural uranium reactor constructed by Heisenberg's team in Berlin had been relocated to Haigerloch. Consequently, the primary objective of the Alsos Mission shifted to these nuclear facilities within the Württemberg region. On May 3, 1945, Heisenberg was clandestinely extracted from Urfeld through an alpine operation conducted in territory still controlled by elite German forces. He was then transported to Heidelberg, where, on May 5, he encountered Goudsmit for the first time since their 1939 meeting in Ann Arbor. Germany's surrender occurred merely two days thereafter. Heisenberg remained separated from his family for eight months, having been transferred across France and Belgium before being flown to England on July 3, 1945.

1945: Response to the Hiroshima Bombing

Nine prominent German scientists, who had contributed reports to Nuclear Physics Research Reports as members of the Uranverein, were apprehended by Operation Alsos and subsequently interned in England under Operation Epsilon. A total of ten German scientists, including Heisenberg, were detained at Farm Hall in England. This facility functioned as a safe house for the British foreign intelligence agency, MI6. Throughout their period of detention, their conversations were systematically recorded. Discussions deemed to possess intelligence value were transcribed and subsequently translated into English. These transcripts were publicly released in 1992. On August 6, 1945, the scientists confined at Farm Hall became aware through media reports that the United States had deployed an atomic bomb in Hiroshima, Japan. Initially, skepticism prevailed regarding the successful construction and deployment of such a weapon. Over the subsequent weeks, the German scientists engaged in discussions concerning the potential methodologies employed by the United States in developing the atomic bomb.

The Farm Hall transcripts indicate that Heisenberg, alongside fellow physicists interned there, such as Otto Hahn and Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker, expressed satisfaction regarding the Allied victory in World War II. Heisenberg informed his colleagues that his focus had always been on developing an atomic pile for energy generation, not on constructing a bomb. Discussions also encompassed the ethical implications of developing a nuclear weapon for the Nazi regime. While only a minority of the scientists articulated profound dismay at the concept of nuclear weaponry, Heisenberg approached the subject with circumspection. Regarding the German nuclear weapons program's inability to construct an atomic bomb, Heisenberg commented, "We would not have possessed the moral fortitude to advise the government in the spring of 1942 to allocate 120,000 personnel solely for its construction."

Upon the declassification of the transcripts in 1992, German physicist Manfred Popp undertook an analysis of both the transcripts and the Uranverein documentation. Following the news of the Hiroshima bombing, Heisenberg confessed that he had not previously calculated the critical mass required for an atomic bomb. His subsequent attempt to determine this mass resulted in significant computational inaccuracies. Edward Teller and Hans Bethe, upon reviewing the transcript, concluded that Heisenberg was performing these calculations for the first time, given the resemblance of his errors to their own initial attempts. Merely a week thereafter, Heisenberg delivered a lecture detailing the physics of the atomic bomb. He accurately identified numerous crucial elements, including the bomb's efficiency, despite still underestimating its full potential. Popp interprets this evidence as demonstrating that Heisenberg did not dedicate efforts to nuclear weapon development during the war; rather, he actively refrained from contemplating it.

Post-War Research Career

Leadership Roles in German Research Institutions

On January 3, 1946, the ten individuals detained under Operation Epsilon were transferred to Alswede, Germany. Heisenberg subsequently established residence in Göttingen, located within the British zone of Allied-occupied Germany. He promptly initiated efforts to advance scientific research throughout Germany. After the Allied Control Council dissolved the Kaiser Wilhelm Society and the Max Planck Society was established in the British zone, Heisenberg assumed the directorship of the Max Planck Institute for Physics. Max von Laue received the appointment of vice director, and Karl Wirtz, Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker, and Ludwig Biermann collaborated with Heisenberg to establish the institute. In 1950, Heinz Billing joined the institute to foster the advancement of electronic computing. The institute's primary research area centered on cosmic radiation. A weekly colloquium was conducted by the institute each Saturday morning.

Heisenberg, in collaboration with Hermann Rein, played a pivotal role in founding the Forschungsrat (research council). Heisenberg envisioned this council as a mechanism to foster communication between the nascent Federal Republic of Germany and the German scientific community. He was subsequently appointed president of the Forschungsrat. In 1951, the organization merged with the Notgemeinschaft der Deutschen Wissenschaft (Emergency Association of German Science) and was concurrently renamed the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (German Research Foundation). Subsequent to this merger, Heisenberg secured an appointment to the presidium.

In 1958, the Max-Planck-Institut für Physik relocated to Munich, underwent expansion, and was subsequently redesignated as the Max-Planck-Institut für Physik und Astrophysik (MPIFA). During this transitional period, Heisenberg and astrophysicist Ludwig Biermann served as co-directors of the MPIFA. Heisenberg also attained the position of an ordentlicher Professor (ordinarius professor) at the University of Munich. From 1960 to 1970, Heisenberg held the sole directorship of the MPIFA. He relinquished his directorship of the MPIFA on December 31, 1970.

Fostering International Scientific Collaboration

In 1951, Heisenberg accepted the role of scientific representative for the Federal Republic of Germany at the UNESCO conference, with the objective of establishing a European nuclear physics laboratory. His ambition was to construct a substantial particle accelerator, leveraging the collective resources and technical expertise of scientists throughout the Western Bloc. On July 1, 1953, Heisenberg formally signed the convention that instituted CERN, acting on behalf of the Federal Republic of Germany. Despite being invited to serve as CERN's inaugural scientific director, he declined the position. Instead, he received an appointment as chair of CERN's science policy committee, subsequently shaping the organization's scientific agenda.

In December 1953, Heisenberg assumed the presidency of the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation. During his tenure, 550 Humboldt scholars from 78 nations received scientific research grants. Heisenberg relinquished his presidential role shortly before his demise.

Research Interests

In 1946, Heinz Pose, the head of Laboratory V in Obninsk, extended an invitation to Heisenberg to work in the USSR. Pose's recruitment letter, hand-delivered on July 18, 1946, lauded the favorable working conditions, abundant resources, and positive disposition of the Soviets toward German scientists. Heisenberg courteously declined the offer. Subsequently, in 1947, Heisenberg delivered lectures in Cambridge, Edinburgh, and Bristol. His contributions to the understanding of superconductivity were documented in a 1947 paper and two 1948 papers, one co-authored with Max von Laue.

In the immediate post-World War II period, Heisenberg briefly revisited the subject of his doctoral thesis, turbulence, publishing three papers in 1948 and one in 1950. Concurrently, he continued his investigations into cosmic-ray showers, focusing on the multiple production of mesons, with three papers published in 1949, two in 1952, and one in 1955.

From late 1955 to early 1956, Heisenberg delivered the Gifford Lectures at St Andrews University in Scotland, focusing on the intellectual history of physics. These lectures were subsequently published as Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science. During 1956 and 1957, Heisenberg chaired the Arbeitskreis Kernphysik (Nuclear Physics Working Group) within the Fachkommission II "Forschung und Nachwuchs" (Commission II "Research and Growth") of the Deutsche Atomkommission (DAtK, German Atomic Energy Commission). Other members of the Nuclear Physics Working Group in both 1956 and 1957 included Walther Bothe, Hans Kopfermann (vice-chairman), Fritz Bopp, Wolfgang Gentner, Otto Haxel, Willibald Jentschke, Heinz Maier-Leibnitz, Josef Mattauch, Wolfgang Riezler, Wilhelm Walcher, and Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker. Wolfgang Paul also joined the group in 1957.

In 1957, Heisenberg became a signatory of the Göttinger Manifest, publicly opposing the Federal Republic of Germany's acquisition of nuclear weapons. Heisenberg, similar to Pascual Jordan, anticipated that politicians might disregard this declaration by nuclear scientists. However, he believed the Göttinger Manifest would "influence public opinion," which politicians would ultimately need to consider. He communicated to Walther Gerlach: "We will probably have to keep coming back to this question in public for a long time because of the danger that public opinion will slacken." In 1961, Heisenberg signed the Memorandum of Tübingen alongside a group of scientists convened by Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker and Ludwig Raiser, which initiated a public discourse between scientists and politicians. As prominent politicians, authors, and socialites engaged in the nuclear weapons debate, the memorandum's signatories took a stance against "the full-time intellectual nonconformists."

From 1957 onwards, Heisenberg developed an interest in plasma physics and the process of nuclear fusion. He also collaborated with the International Institute of Atomic Physics in Geneva, serving as a member of its scientific policy committee and chairing the committee for several years. He was one of the eight signatories of the Memorandum of Tübingen, which advocated for the recognition of the Oder–Neiße line as the official border between Germany and Poland and opposed the potential nuclear armament of West Germany.

In 1973, Heisenberg delivered a lecture at Harvard University concerning the historical evolution of quantum theory concepts. On March 24, 1973, he presented a speech to the Catholic Academy of Bavaria upon accepting the Romano Guardini Prize. An English translation of this address was published under the title "Scientific and Religious Truth."

Philosophy and Worldview

Heisenberg expressed admiration for Eastern philosophy, identifying significant parallels with quantum mechanics, and declared "complete agreement" with the book The Tao of Physics. He further noted that discussions with Rabindranath Tagore on Indian philosophy clarified certain concepts that had previously appeared unconventional. Regarding natural laws, Heisenberg posited that "the concept of 'the law of nature' cannot be completely objective, the word 'law' being a purely human principle."

Concerning Ludwig Wittgenstein's philosophical contributions, Heisenberg expressed disapproval of Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, yet he held a strong appreciation for Wittgenstein's subsequent theories, particularly those pertaining to the philosophy of language.

In his final correspondence with Albert Einstein, Heisenberg, a devout Christian, articulated: "We can console ourselves that the good Lord God would know the position of the [subatomic] particles, thus He would let the causality principle continue to have validity." Conversely, Einstein consistently argued for the incompleteness of quantum physics, citing its implication of fundamental indeterminacy within the universe.

During lectures delivered in the 1950s, subsequently compiled and published as Physics and Philosophy, Heisenberg asserted that scientific progress was generating cultural discord. He further declared that modern physics constitutes "part of a general historical process that tends toward a unification and a widening of our present world."

Upon receiving the Romano Guardini Prize in 1974, Heisenberg delivered an address, which he subsequently published under the title Scientific and Religious Truth. In this discourse, he reflected:

Throughout the history of science, particularly since the notable trial of Galileo, assertions have frequently been made that scientific truth is irreconcilable with a religious worldview. While I am now persuaded that scientific truth is inviolable within its domain, I have consistently found it impossible to disregard the substance of religious thought as merely an antiquated stage in human consciousness, something to be abandoned henceforth. Consequently, over the course of my life, I have repeatedly been compelled to contemplate the interrelationship between these two intellectual spheres, as I have never been able to question the reality of that to which they refer.

Heisenberg characterized nature as "God's second book," with the Bible being the first, and posited that "Physics is reflection on the divine ideas of Creation; therefore physics is divine service." This perspective stemmed from his belief that "God created the world in accordance with his ideas of creation" and that humanity possesses the capacity to comprehend the world because "Man was created as the spiritual image of God."

Political Stance

Heisenberg did not engage in overt National Socialist propaganda; however, he fully endorsed Nazi Germany's vision for European "renewal," aligning with his German-imperialist beliefs. Hendrik Casimir, a Dutch physicist, recounted Heisenberg's assertion in 1943 that German global hegemony was historically inevitable, attributable to the perceived fragility of Western liberal democracy and the threat of Soviet Communism. British-German physicist Rudolf Peierls reported that during a 1947 " Austrian-Swedish physicist Lise Meitner cited Heisenberg's 1948 response when confronted with German atrocities: "Unfortunately, every spiritual upheaval has always been accompanied by great cruelty."

Heisenberg, who remained in Germany throughout the Nazi regime, also demonstrated an unwillingness to emigrate following the war. In 1951, when presented with an offer of permanent endowed employment at Yale University by Gregory Breit, he indicated that he would have only considered it if World War III had commenced and the Soviet Union had occupied Göttingen.

Autobiography and Demise

In his late sixties, Heisenberg authored his autobiography, targeting a broad readership. The book was initially released in Germany in 1969, followed by an English edition in early 1971, and subsequent translations into numerous other languages. Heisenberg commenced this autobiographical project in 1966, a period when his public discourses increasingly explored philosophical and religious themes. Earlier, Heisenberg had submitted a manuscript for a textbook on unified field theory to Hirzel Verlag and John Wiley & Sons for publication, describing it to one publisher as preliminary work for his forthcoming autobiography. The autobiography was thematically organized, addressing: 1) The objective of precise scientific inquiry, 2) Linguistic challenges in atomic physics, 3) Abstraction in mathematics and scientific disciplines, 4) The divisibility of matter, or Kant's antinomy, 5) Fundamental symmetry and its validation, and 6) The relationship between science and religion.

Heisenberg structured his memoirs as a series of conversations, chronicling his life's trajectory. While achieving popular success, the book encountered skepticism from historians of science. In its preface, Heisenberg acknowledged having condensed historical events for brevity. Upon its release, Paul Forman reviewed the work in the journal Science, remarking: "Now here is a memoir in the form of rationally reconstructed dialogue. And the dialogue as Galileo well knew, is itself a most insidious literary device: lively, entertaining, and especially suited for insinuating opinions while yet evading responsibility for them." At that time, scientific memoirs were uncommon; however, Konrad Lorenz and Adolf Portmann had previously authored popular works that effectively communicated scholarly concepts to a broad readership. Heisenberg completed his autobiography, which was subsequently published by Piper Verlag in Munich. His initial proposed title was Gespräche im Umkreis der Atomphysik (Conversations on Atomic Physics). Ultimately, the autobiography was published under the title Der Teil und das Ganze (The Part and the Whole). The 1971 English translation bore the title Physics and Beyond: Encounters and Conversations.

Heisenberg passed away from kidney cancer at his residence on February 1, 1976. The following evening, his colleagues and friends conducted a commemorative procession from the Institute of Physics to his home, where they lit a candle and placed it at his doorway. Heisenberg's remains are interred in the Munich Waldfriedhof.

In 1980, his widow, Elisabeth Heisenberg, authored Das politische Leben eines Unpolitischen (The Political Life of an Apolitical Person), wherein she described Heisenberg as "primarily a spontaneous individual, subsequently a brilliant scientist, then a highly talented artist, and only fourthly, out of a sense of duty, a homo politicus."

Honors and Awards

Heisenberg received numerous distinctions:

Research Reports on Nuclear Physics

The subsequent reports were disseminated within Kernphysikalische Forschungsberichte (Research Reports in Nuclear Physics), an internal publication of the German Uranverein. These documents were designated Top Secret, had restricted circulation, and authors were prohibited from retaining copies. Following their confiscation during the Allied Operation Alsos, the reports were dispatched to the United States Atomic Energy Commission for assessment. In 1971, they were declassified and repatriated to Germany. Currently, these reports are accessible at the Karlsruhe Nuclear Research Center and the American Institute of Physics.

Other research publications