TORIma Academy Logo TORIma Academy
Lewis Carroll
Literature

Lewis Carroll

TORIma Academy — Children's Literature

Lewis Carroll

Lewis Carroll

Charles Lutwidge Dodgson (27 January 1832 – 14 January 1898), better known by his pen name Lewis Carroll , was an English author, poet, mathematician,…

Charles Lutwidge Dodgson (27 January 1832 – 14 January 1898), widely recognized by his pseudonym Lewis Carroll, was an English polymath, excelling as an author, poet, mathematician, photographer, and an Anglican deacon who served with some reluctance. Among his most celebrated contributions to Victorian literature are Alice's Adventures in Wonderland (1865) and its subsequent volume, Through the Looking-Glass (1871). Carroll was particularly renowned for his adeptness in wordplay, logical constructs, and imaginative fantasy. His poetic works, including Jabberwocky (1871) and The Hunting of the Snark (1876), are seminal examples within the literary nonsense genre. The whimsical logic prevalent in Alice's Wonderland narratives often mirrors his scholarly publications on mathematical logic.

Originating from a family of High Church Anglicans, Carroll undertook his clerical education at Christ Church, Oxford. He resided there for the majority of his life, serving as a scholar, teacher, and, due to the requirements of his academic fellowship, an Anglican deacon. Alice Liddell, daughter of Henry Liddell, the Dean of Christ Church, is frequently cited as the primary inspiration for Alice in Wonderland, a claim Carroll consistently refuted.

As an enthusiastic creator of puzzles, Carroll devised the word ladder puzzle, which he named "Doublets." This invention was featured in Vanity Fair magazine from 1879 to 1881. A memorial stone honoring Carroll was dedicated in 1982 at Poets' Corner within Westminster Abbey. Globally, numerous societies are devoted to appreciating and advancing his literary legacy.

Early life

Dodgson's familial origins were primarily Northern English, characterized by conservative values and adherence to High Church Anglicanism. A significant number of his male forebears served either as army officers or as Anglican clergy. His great-grandfather, Charles Dodgson, ascended the ecclesiastical hierarchy to become the Bishop of Elphin in rural Ireland. His paternal grandfather, also named Charles, an army captain, perished during the Irish rebellion of 1803, leaving his two young sons as infants. The elder of these sons, another Charles Dodgson, was Carroll's father. He attended Rugby School before matriculating at Christ Church, a constituent college of the University of Oxford. He subsequently embraced the alternative family tradition by entering holy orders. Possessing considerable mathematical talent, he achieved a double first-class degree, a distinction that could have heralded a distinguished academic career. However, he ultimately chose to serve as a country parson.

Dodgson was born on 27 January 1832, at All Saints' Vicarage in Daresbury, Cheshire. He was the eldest son and the third of eleven children. At the age of eleven, his father received the ecclesiastical living of Croft-on-Tees, Yorkshire, prompting the family's relocation to a sizable rectory. This residence served as their family home for the subsequent 25 years. Charles's father was a prominent and staunchly conservative cleric within the Church of England. He later attained the position of Archdeacon of Richmond and actively participated, at times with considerable influence, in the fervent theological debates that fragmented the church. Adhering to High Church principles, he leaned towards Anglo-Catholicism, admired John Henry Newman and the Tractarian movement, and diligently endeavored to impart these perspectives to his offspring. Nevertheless, Charles cultivated an ambivalent stance regarding his father's convictions and the broader Church of England.

In his early youth, Dodgson received his education at home. Family archives containing his "reading lists" indicate a precocious intellect; by the age of seven, he was engaging with works like The Pilgrim's Progress. He also experienced a stammer, a trait common among most of his siblings, which frequently hindered his social interactions throughout his life. At twelve years old, he was enrolled in Richmond School (subsequently known as Richmond Grammar School and later incorporated into the comprehensive Richmond School) in Richmond, North Yorkshire. In 1846, Dodgson commenced his studies at Rugby School, where he was demonstrably discontented. Years after his departure, he wrote: "I cannot say ... that any earthly considerations would induce me to go through my three years again ... I can honestly say that if I could have been ... secure from annoyance at night, the hardships of the daily life would have been comparative trifles to bear." While he did not assert that he personally endured bullying, he identified younger boys as the primary victims of older bullies at Rugby. Stuart Dodgson Collingwood, Dodgson's nephew, recorded that "even though it is hard for those who have only known him as the gentle and retiring don to believe it, it is nevertheless true that long after he left school, his name was remembered as that of a boy who knew well how to use his fists in defence of a righteous cause," specifically referring to the protection of smaller boys.

Charles Dodgson demonstrated exceptional academic aptitude with remarkable ease. R. B. Mayor, his mathematics master, noted his potential, stating, "I have not had a more promising boy at his age since I came to Rugby." The mathematics textbook utilized by the young Dodgson, Francis Walkingame's The Tutor's Assistant; Being a Compendium of Arithmetic, is extant and features a Latin inscription translating to: "This book belongs to Charles Lutwidge Dodgson: hands off!" Furthermore, certain pages contained annotations, such as one on page 129 where he critiqued a problem by writing, "Not a fair question in decimals." He departed Rugby in late 1849 and subsequently matriculated at the University of Oxford in May 1850, joining Christ Church, his father's former college. Following a period awaiting available college accommodation, he commenced residence in January 1851. Merely two days after his arrival at Oxford, he was urgently called home. His mother had passed away at 47 from "inflammation of the brain," possibly meningitis or a stroke.

His initial academic trajectory was characterized by a fluctuation between significant potential and compelling diversions. Although not consistently diligent, he possessed extraordinary talent, and academic success often came effortlessly. In 1852, he achieved first-class honors in mathematics moderations and was subsequently nominated for a studentship by Canon Edward Pusey, a long-standing friend of his father. By 1854, he secured first-class honors in the Final Honours School of Mathematics, ranking first, and consequently earned his Bachelor of Arts degree. He continued at Christ Church, engaging in study and teaching; however, the following year, he failed a crucial scholarship examination, attributing this to his acknowledged difficulty in sustained application to academic work. Nevertheless, his mathematical prowess led to his appointment as the Christ Church Mathematical Lecturer in 1855, a position he maintained for the subsequent 26 years. Despite initial dissatisfaction, Dodgson remained at Christ Church in various roles until his death, notably serving as sub-librarian of the Christ Church library, with his office situated near the deanery, the residence of Alice Liddell.

Character and appearance

Health problems

As a young adult, Charles Dodgson was approximately 6 feet (1.83 m) tall and slender, possessing curly brown hair and eyes described as either blue or grey. In his later years, he was characterized by a slight asymmetry and a somewhat stiff, awkward gait, potentially attributable to a knee injury sustained during middle age. During early childhood, he experienced a fever that resulted in deafness in one ear. At 17, he endured a severe bout of whooping cough, likely contributing to his chronic chest weakness in adulthood. He developed a stammer in early childhood, which he termed his "hesitation," and it persisted throughout his life.

Dodgson's stammer has consistently been a notable aspect of his public perception. An unsubstantiated anecdote suggests he stammered exclusively among adults and spoke fluently with children; however, no evidence corroborates this claim. Numerous children who knew him recalled his stammer, whereas many adults did not perceive it. Dodgson appeared to be considerably more conscious of his stammer than most individuals he encountered. It is commonly asserted that he caricatured himself as the Dodo in Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, alluding to his difficulty pronouncing his surname; however, this is among many frequently repeated claims lacking primary evidence. While he did refer to himself as a dodo, the connection of this reference to his stammer remains speculative.

Although Dodgson's stammer caused him distress, it was never so incapacitating as to hinder his effective utilization of other personal attributes in social contexts. During an era when individuals frequently created their own entertainment and when singing and recitation were essential social competencies, the young Dodgson was well-suited to be an engaging performer. He was reportedly capable of singing adequately and performed without hesitation before an audience. Furthermore, he demonstrated proficiency in mimicry and storytelling, and was reputedly skilled at charades.

Social connections

Between the publication of his initial works and the triumph of the Alice books, Dodgson integrated into the Pre-Raphaelite social sphere. His first encounter with John Ruskin occurred in 1857, leading to a friendship. By approximately 1863, he established a close association with Dante Gabriel Rossetti and his family. He frequently photographed the family in the garden of the Rossetti residence in Chelsea, London. Additionally, he was acquainted with William Holman Hunt, John Everett Millais, and Arthur Hughes, among other notable artists. He maintained a strong acquaintance with fairy-tale author George MacDonald; indeed, the enthusiastic reception of Alice by MacDonald's young children ultimately convinced him to submit the manuscript for publication.

Politics, religion, and philosophy

Charles Dodgson is widely considered to have held conservative views in political, religious, and personal spheres. Martin Gardner characterized Dodgson as a Tory, noting his deference to nobility and a tendency towards snobbery concerning those he considered his social inferiors. In his 1900 work, Reminiscences of Oxford, William Tuckwell described Dodgson as "austere, shy, precise, absorbed in mathematical reverie, watchfully tenacious of his dignity, stiffly conservative in political, theological, social theory, his life mapped out in squares like Alice's landscape". On December 22, 1861, Dodgson was ordained a deacon in the Church of England, a requirement for college dons at the time from which he did not obtain an exemption. According to the editor of The Life and Letters of Lewis Carroll, Dodgson's diary contained "modest depreciations of himself and his work, interspersed with earnest prayers (too sacred and private to be reproduced here) that God would forgive him the past, and help him to perform His holy will in the future." When questioned about his religious convictions by a friend, Dodgson responded that he belonged to the Church of England, though he "doubt[ed] if he was fully a 'High Churchman'". He further elaborated:

I believe that when you and I come to lie down for the last time, if only we can keep firm hold of the great truths Christ taught us — our own utter worthlessness and His infinite worth; and that He has brought us back to our one Father, and made us His brethren, and so brethren to one another—we shall have all we need to guide us through the shadows. Most assuredly I accept to the full the doctrines you refer to—that Christ died to save us, that we have no other way of salvation open to us but through His death, and that it is by faith in Him, and through no merit of ours, that we are reconciled to God; and most assuredly I can cordially say, "I owe all to Him who loved me, and died on the Cross of Calvary."

Dodgson's intellectual curiosity extended beyond his primary disciplines. He became an early member of the Society for Psychical Research, and correspondence indicates his belief in what was then termed "thought reading". Dodgson also authored several analyses of philosophical arguments. In 1895, his article "What the Tortoise Said to Achilles", published in an early volume of Mind, presented a philosophical regress argument concerning deductive reasoning. This article was subsequently reprinted in the same journal in 1995, a century after its initial publication, accompanied by a new article from Simon Blackburn titled "Practical Tortoise Raising".

Artistic activities

Literature

From an early age, Dodgson composed poetry and short stories, making substantial contributions to the family magazine Mischmasch before submitting his work to various other publications, where he achieved moderate success. Between 1854 and 1856, his writings were featured in national periodicals like The Comic Times and The Train, in addition to regional publications such as the Whitby Gazette and the Oxford Critic. While much of this early output was humorous, and occasionally satirical, Dodgson maintained rigorous standards and high ambitions for his writing. In July 1855, he articulated his aspirations, stating: "I do not think I have yet written anything worthy of real publication (in which I do not include the Whitby Gazette or the Oxonian Advertiser), but I do not despair of doing so someday." After 1850, he authored marionette plays for his siblings' amusement; one such play, La Guida di Bragia, is still extant.

In March 1856, Dodgson published his inaugural work under the pseudonym that would later bring him widespread recognition. The romantic poem "Solitude" was published in The Train, attributed to "Lewis Carroll". This chosen pseudonym was a linguistic derivation of his actual name: Lewis represented the Anglicized form of Ludovicus, the Latin equivalent of Lutwidge, while Carroll was an Irish surname bearing resemblance to the Latin Carolus, the root of Charles. The transformation involved translating "Charles Lutwidge" into Latin as "Carolus Ludovicus", then re-translating it into English as "Carroll Lewis", and finally reversing the order to form "Lewis Carroll". Editor Edmund Yates selected this pseudonym from a list of four options provided by Dodgson, which also included Edgar Cuthwellis, Edgar U. C. Westhill, and Louis Carroll.

Alice books

In 1856, Dean Henry Liddell's arrival at Christ Church, Oxford University, with his young family significantly impacted Dodgson's life and writing career in subsequent years. Dodgson cultivated a close friendship with Liddell's wife, Lorina, and their children, especially the three sisters: Lorina, Edith, and Alice Liddell. For many years, it was widely presumed that Dodgson's character "Alice" was inspired by Alice Liddell. This assumption was supported by an acrostic poem at the conclusion of Through the Looking-Glass, which spells out her full name, and numerous subtle allusions to her embedded within both texts. However, Dodgson consistently refuted in his later years that his "little heroine" was modeled after any specific child. He often dedicated his works to young female acquaintances, incorporating their names into acrostic poems at the commencement of the text. For instance, Gertrude Chataway's name is featured in this manner at the beginning of The Hunting of the Snark, yet this does not imply that any characters in that narrative are based on her.

Although information from this period is limited due to the absence of Dodgson's diaries for 1858–1862, his friendship with the Liddell family evidently constituted a significant aspect of his life in the late 1850s. He regularly took the children, initially Harry and subsequently the three girls, on rowing excursions to nearby Nuneham Courtenay or Godstow, always accompanied by an adult friend. During one such expedition on July 4, 1862, Dodgson conceived the foundational narrative that would later become his inaugural and most significant commercial triumph. After recounting the story to Alice Liddell, who implored him to record it, Dodgson ultimately presented her with a handwritten, illustrated manuscript titled Alice's Adventures Under Ground in November 1864, following a considerable delay.

Prior to this, the family of his friend and mentor, George MacDonald, reviewed Dodgson's incomplete manuscript, and the children's enthusiastic reception prompted Dodgson to pursue publication. In 1863, he submitted the unfinished manuscript to Macmillan, the publisher, who promptly expressed approval. Following the rejection of alternative titles, including Alice Among the Fairies and Alice's Golden Hour, an expanded and significantly revised version of the work was ultimately published as Alice's Adventures in Wonderland in 1865. This publication utilized the pseudonym Lewis Carroll, which Dodgson had adopted approximately nine years prior. Sir John Tenniel provided the illustrations for this edition, as Dodgson apparently believed a published work necessitated the expertise of a professional artist. Annotated editions offer elucidation into the numerous concepts and concealed meanings pervasive throughout these texts. Critical scholarship frequently presents Freudian interpretations, characterizing the book as "a descent into the dark world of the subconscious," and also views it as a satirical commentary on contemporary mathematical developments.

The immense commercial success of the initial Alice book profoundly transformed Dodgson's life. The renown of his alter ego, "Lewis Carroll," rapidly achieved global recognition. He received an abundance of fan mail and, at times, unwelcome public scrutiny. A popular anecdote suggests that Queen Victoria, captivated by Alice in Wonderland, purportedly commanded Dodgson to dedicate his subsequent work to her. Consequently, she was allegedly presented with his next publication, a scholarly mathematical treatise titled An Elementary Treatise on Determinants. Dodgson, however, vehemently refuted this account, stating, "... It is utterly false in every particular: nothing even resembling it has occurred." This narrative is also improbable for additional reasons. As T. B. Strong observed in a Times article, "It would have been clean contrary to all his practice to identify [the] author of Alice with the author of his mathematical works." Despite commencing to earn substantial income, he maintained his seemingly disfavored position at Christ Church.

In late 1871, Dodgson released the sequel, Through the Looking-Glass, and What Alice Found There. The first edition's title page incorrectly lists "1872" as its publication date. The work's perceptibly darker tone may reflect shifts in Dodgson's personal circumstances. His father's demise in 1868 precipitated a multi-year period of depression.

The Hunting of the Snark

In 1876, Dodgson published The Hunting of the Snark, a fantastical nonsense poem illustrated by Henry Holiday. This work chronicles the adventures of an unusual crew, comprising nine tradesmen and a beaver, on their quest to locate the Snark. While contemporary critics offered mixed reviews, the poem achieved immense public popularity, undergoing seventeen reprints between 1876 and 1908. It has also been adapted into various forms, including musicals, opera, and theatrical productions. Notably, painter Dante Gabriel Rossetti reportedly believed the poem was a satirical depiction of himself.

Sylvie and Bruno

In 1895, three decades after his initial publications, Carroll sought to re-establish his literary presence with Sylvie and Bruno, a two-volume narrative featuring the fairy siblings. The narrative intricately weaves together two distinct plots, unfolding in parallel worlds: one in rural England and the other within the fantastical realms of Elfland, Outland, and similar kingdoms. The fairytale setting serves as a satirical commentary on English society, particularly targeting the academic sphere. Although Sylvie and Bruno is generally regarded as a minor work, it has remained continuously in print for more than a century since its two-volume release.

Photography (1856–1880)

Dodgson began practicing photography, a nascent art form, in 1856, initially influenced by his uncle Skeffington Lutwidge and subsequently by his Oxford associate Reginald Southey. He rapidly achieved proficiency, establishing himself as a prominent gentleman-photographer, and reportedly considered pursuing photography professionally during his early career. A comprehensive study by Roger Taylor and Edward Wakeling meticulously catalogs all extant prints, with Taylor's analysis indicating that over half of Dodgson's surviving photographic output features young girls. Among the surviving photographs, thirty portray nude or semi-nude children. Approximately 60% of Dodgson's initial photographic collection was intentionally destroyed. Dodgson's photographic subjects also encompassed men, women, boys, and landscapes, as well as skeletons, dolls, dogs, statues, paintings, and trees.

Photographs of children were taken with a parent present, and many were captured in the Liddell garden due to the necessity of natural sunlight for optimal exposures. Furthermore, Dodgson utilized photography as a means to gain access to elevated social circles. During his most prolific period, he produced portraits of distinguished individuals, including John Everett Millais, Ellen Terry, Maggie Spearman, Dante Gabriel Rossetti, Julia Margaret Cameron, Michael Faraday, Lord Salisbury, and Alfred Tennyson.

When Dodgson abruptly discontinued photography in 1880, after 24 years, he had established a studio on the roof of Tom Quad and produced approximately 3,000 images, becoming an amateur master of the medium. However, fewer than 1,000 of these images have survived the passage of time and intentional destruction. His cessation of photography was attributed to the considerable time commitment required to maintain his studio operations. Dodgson employed the wet collodion process, whereas commercial photographers, adopting the dry-plate process in the 1870s, could capture images more rapidly. He frequently modified his photographs using blurring techniques or by overpainting them. Through this craft, he asserted his artistic agency by reinterpreting the visual narrative of images to foster a new discourse on childhood. Nevertheless, the emergence of Modernism shifted popular aesthetic preferences, influencing the nature of his photographic output.

Inventions

In 1889, Dodgson invented "The Wonderland Postage-Stamp Case" to encourage letter writing. This device consisted of a cloth-backed folder featuring twelve slots: two designated for the prevalent penny stamp, and one each for other denominations up to one shilling. The folder was housed within a slipcase adorned with an illustration of Alice on the front and the Cheshire Cat on the back. Its purpose was to organize stamps alongside writing implements; Carroll explicitly stated in Eight or Nine Wise Words about Letter-Writing that it was not designed for pocket or purse carry, given that common individual stamps could be easily transported independently. The product bundle also contained a pamphlet version of this lecture.

Dodgson also invented the nyctograph, a writing tablet designed for note-taking in darkness, thereby removing the necessity of rising to illuminate a room when an idea arose. This device comprised a gridded card featuring sixteen squares and an alphabet system of Dodgson's own creation, utilizing letter shapes reminiscent of the Graffiti writing system found on Palm devices. Furthermore, Dodgson conceived several games, among them an early iteration of the game now recognized as Scrabble. Around 1878, he developed the "doublet," a word puzzle (also known as a word ladder) that remains popular, requiring the transformation of one word into another by changing a single letter at each step, with every intermediate word being valid. An illustrative example demonstrates the transformation of CAT into DOG through the sequence: CAT, COT, DOT, DOG. This puzzle debuted in the March 29, 1879, issue of Vanity Fair, where Carroll contributed a weekly column for two years, concluding on April 9, 1881.

Lewis Carroll's games and puzzles were featured in Martin Gardner's "Mathematical Games" column in the March 1960 issue of Scientific American. His other inventions and proposals encompassed a method for determining the day of the week for any given date, a technique for right-margin justification on typewriters, a steering mechanism for a velociman (a type of tricycle), improved elimination rules for tennis tournaments, a novel postal money order system, guidelines for calculating postage, betting win conditions, rules for numerical division by various divisors, a cardboard scale for Christ Church's Senior Common Room designed to ensure precise liqueur measurements when held against a glass, a double-sided adhesive strip for sealing envelopes or affixing items in books, an apparatus to assist bedridden individuals in reading sideways-placed books, and at least two cryptographic ciphers.

Dodgson also advanced alternative frameworks for parliamentary representation. He introduced "Dodgson's method," which incorporated principles of the Condorcet method. In 1884, he outlined a proportional representation system featuring multi-member districts, single-vote casting per voter, quotas as minimum thresholds for seat allocation, and candidate-transferable votes, a concept now referred to as liquid democracy.

Mathematical work

In the academic domain of mathematics, Dodgson's primary focus areas included geometry, linear and matrix algebra, mathematical logic, and recreational mathematics, resulting in the publication of nearly a dozen books under his birth name. He also originated novel concepts in linear algebra, such as the initial published proof of the Rouché–Capelli theorem, as well as contributions to probability theory and the analysis of elections and committees, exemplified by Dodgson's method. A portion of this scholarly output remained unpublished until significantly after his demise. His role as a Mathematical Lecturer at Christ Church provided him with a degree of financial stability.

Mathematical logic

Dodgson's contributions to mathematical logic experienced a resurgence of interest during the late 20th century. A reevaluation of Dodgson's impact on symbolic logic was prompted by Martin Gardner's publication concerning logic machines and diagrams, alongside William Warren Bartley's posthumous release of the second volume of Dodgson's work on symbolic logic. Notably, in Symbolic Logic Part II, Dodgson is credited with introducing the Method of Trees, representing the earliest modern application of a truth tree.

Algebra

The research conducted by Robbins and Rumsey into Dodgson condensation, a technique for determinant evaluation, culminated in the alternating sign matrix conjecture, which has since been proven as a theorem.

Recreational mathematics

The identification of further ciphers developed by Dodgson in the 1990s, complementing his "Memoria Technica," demonstrated his application of advanced mathematical concepts in their design.

Correspondence

Based on a specialized letter register he created, Dodgson reportedly composed and received 98,721 letters. His recommendations for crafting more effective correspondence were compiled in an essay titled "Eight or Nine Wise Words about Letter-Writing," which was published in 1890.

Later life

Despite increasing wealth and fame, Dodgson's life remained largely consistent during its final two decades. He maintained his teaching position at Christ Church until 1881 and resided there until his passing. Notable public engagements included his attendance at the West End musical Alice in Wonderland, the inaugural significant live adaptation of his Alice books, at the Prince of Wales Theatre on December 30, 1886. His final novel, Sylvie and Bruno, was released in two volumes in 1889 and 1893. However, its complex narrative and employment of "babytalk" seemingly failed to resonate with contemporary audiences, resulting in critical disappointment and sales of merely 13,000 copies, a stark contrast to the success of the Alice books.

Dodgson's sole documented international journey occurred in 1867, when he traveled to Russia as an ecclesiastic alongside Reverend Henry Liddon. This journey is chronicled in his "Russian Journal," first commercially published in 1935. During his outbound and return travels, he visited various cities across Belgium, Germany, partitioned Poland and Lithuania, and France. In his early sixties, Dodgson experienced a worsening condition of synovitis, which progressively impaired his mobility and occasionally confined him to bed for extended periods.

Death

Dodgson passed away from pneumonia, a complication of influenza, on January 14, 1898, at "The Chestnuts," his sisters' residence in Guildford, Surrey, just under two weeks prior to his 66th birthday. His funeral service took place at the adjacent St Mary's Church. Interment occurred at Mount Cemetery in Guildford. In 1935, All Saints' Church in Daresbury honored Dodgson with stained glass windows featuring characters from Alice's Adventures in Wonderland.

Controversies and mysteries

The Secret World of Lewis Carroll (2015) BBC documentary

In 2015, the BBC documentary The Secret World of Lewis Carroll critically analyzed Dodgson's relationships with Alice Liddell and her sisters. Produced by Swan Films and directed by Clare Beavan, the documentary is structured in two parts. The second segment investigated the hypothesis that a disagreement between Dodgson and the Liddell family, alongside his temporary college suspension, may have stemmed from inappropriate interactions with their children, including Alice. During its research, the documentary team discovered a "disturbing" full-frontal nude photograph of Alice's adolescent sister, Lorina, and posited the "likelihood" that Dodgson was the photographer. This photograph is held in the archives of the Musée Cantini in Marseille, where an unknown hand had attributed it to "L. Carroll."

Carroll scholar Edward Wakeling subsequently disclosed in early 2015 that the photograph initially surfaced in the 1970s, then held by Parisian photo collectors. The photograph's purported connection to Dodgson was questionable. It belonged to a collection acquired by the Musée Cantini in 1994. Crucially, no connection to Dodgson or the Liddell family was established, a fact omitted from the documentary. The documentary fostered suspicions regarding Dodgson as a "repressed paedophile," a characterization voiced by interviewee Will Self. This particular angle was prematurely reported by The Telegraph a week prior to broadcast. In their reviews, newspapers attempted to associate the 19th-century Carroll with contemporary revelations concerning sexual misconduct by recent paedophiles. This associative effort might be interpreted as scapegoating, influenced by media responses to the UK's Yewtree investigations in the early 2010s. Concerns regarding the documentary's methodology and research were subsequently reported by The Times and The Telegraph.

The documentary's content faced significant criticism from Carroll scholars, including participants Jenny Woolf and Edward Wakeling. Woolf stated she was not informed about the alleged photo's inclusion until the documentary's editing phase. Edward Wakeling's paper, "Eight or nine wise words on documentary making," was published in March 2015 in the Lewis Carroll Society newsletter Bandersnatch. Wakeling corroborated Woolf's claim, asserting he was not afforded an opportunity to discuss the disputed photograph. Wakeling contended that the documentary producers withheld the photo from him, despite knowing his ability to authenticate it, because they anticipated his reaction. In his paper, Wakeling additionally critiqued the Cantini photo's authenticity, the BBC's omission in informing participants about the discovered photograph, and several factual inaccuracies. Wakeling highlighted the photograph's irregularly "trimmed" appearance and the absence of Dodgson's handwriting. He noted that the pencil inscription "lewis Carroll" on the photo's reverse was in an "unknown hand," suggesting it "could have been written by anybody." Furthermore, the photo negative lacked the personal catalogue number Dodgson meticulously used for his photographs. Dodgson's standard practice involved adding a number to the back of any prints he developed. Wakeling also observed that Dodgson never produced "full frontal studies," especially of a girl of that age, stating, "There's no way the Liddells would have allowed a picture of this kind to have been taken."

The authorship of the photograph by Dodgson remains unconfirmed, as does the identity of the person who wrote the pencil inscription on its reverse and their motivation. This photograph was omitted from Wakeling's catalogue raisonné of Dodgson's complete surviving photographs and has not been featured in subsequent documentaries about Dodgson. Subsequently, the BBC Trust determined that the documentary could not be re-broadcast on UK television in its existing format, citing the BBC's failure to inform participants about the photo's inclusion during filming or allow them adequate time to respond.

Speculation of sexual conduct by scholars (1940s onwards)

Several late 20th-century biographers have posited that Dodgson's interest in children may have contained an "erotic" component. These include Morton N. Cohen in his 1995 work Lewis Carroll: A Biography,Donald Thomas in his 1995 book Lewis Carroll: A Portrait with Background, and Michael Bakewell in his 1996 biography Lewis Carroll: A Biography. Cohen specifically theorizes that Dodgson's "sexual energies sought unconventional outlets," elaborating:

We cannot know to what extent sexual urges lay behind Charles's preference for drawing and photographing children in the nude. He contended the preference was entirely aesthetic. But given his emotional attachment to children as well as his aesthetic appreciation of their forms, his assertion that his interest was strictly artistic is naïve. He probably felt more than he dared acknowledge, even to himself.

Cohen further observes that Dodgson "apparently convinced many of his friends that his attachment to the nude female child form was free of any eroticism," but suggests that "later generations look beneath the surface" (p. 229). Cohen posits that Dodgson might have desired to marry the 11-year-old Alice Liddell, attributing this as the reason for the unexplained "break" with her family in June 1863,though alternative explanations for this event exist. Biographers Derek Hudson and Roger Lancelyn Green, while not explicitly labeling Dodgson a paedophile (Green also edited Dodgson's diaries and papers), agree that he possessed a strong affection for young female children and showed minimal interest in the adult world. Catherine Robson describes Carroll as "the Victorian era's most famous (or infamous) girl lover." Media studies scholar Will Brooker notes that the 20th-century perception of Dodgson in this manner was significantly shaped by Sigmund Freud's theories. Brooker views Dodgson's purported perversion as a cultural artifact that, originating in its specific era, persisted beyond its cultural relevance:

The psychoanalytic [Freudian] interpretations of the Alice books in the 1930s were a product of a specific moment and movement... The discourses that I traced in journalism and in some biographies, that Carroll was emotionally arrested, a repressed paedophile, an obsessive, stammering social reject... -- have more to do with our own attitudes to childhood and celebrity than they do to the culture Carroll lived through.

<

Other scholars have disputed the evidentiary foundation for claims made by Cohen and others regarding Dodgson's potentially exploitative conduct. Hugues Lebailly, for instance, has contextualized Dodgson's child photography within the "Victorian Child Cult," a cultural phenomenon that regarded child nudity as an inherent manifestation of innocence. Lebailly asserts that Dodgson's diaries frequently document his admiration for adult women, including their portrayal in art and theatre, and even in "vulgar" forms of entertainment. While Dodgson's nieces expunged these references from early diary manuscripts, they retained entries pertaining to children, as the appreciation for children was not contentious during that era.Lebailly contends that the depiction of child nudes was a prevalent and fashionable practice in Dodgson's era, with most photographers, such as Oscar Gustave Rejlander and Julia Margaret Cameron, routinely producing such images. He further notes that child nudes were even featured on Victorian Christmas cards, indicating a distinct social and aesthetic perception of this subject matter. Lebailly concludes that Dodgson's biographers have erred by interpreting his child photography through a 20th- or 21st-century lens, presenting it as a personal eccentricity rather than a reflection of a dominant aesthetic and philosophical trend of his period.

Karoline Leach's reevaluation of Dodgson specifically addressed his contentious engagement with child nudity. Leach contends that accusations of paedophilia originated from a misinterpretation of Victorian moral standards and the erroneous belief, perpetuated by Dodgson's biographers, that he lacked interest in adult women. She designated this conventional portrayal of Dodgson as "the Carroll Myth." Leach highlighted extensive evidence in his diaries and correspondence indicating his profound interest in adult women, both married and single, and his involvement in several relationships that would have been deemed scandalous by contemporary social norms. She further noted that many individuals he referred to as "child-friends" were, in fact, young women in their late teens and early twenties. Leach posits that allegations of paedophilia surfaced decades after his demise, following his family's well-intentioned suppression of evidence concerning his relationships with women, an act intended to safeguard his reputation but which inadvertently created a misleading impression of a man exclusively interested in young girls. Moreover, Leach identifies a 1932 biography by Langford Reed as the origin of the questionable assertion that many of Carroll's female friendships ceased upon the girls reaching the age of 14.

Ordination

From an early age, Dodgson was prepared for ordained ministry within the Church of England, with ordination expected within four years of his master's degree as a prerequisite for his residency at Christ Church. Although he postponed the process, he was eventually ordained as a deacon on December 22, 1861. However, a year later, when priestly ordination was due, Dodgson petitioned the dean for dispensation from proceeding. This request contravened college regulations, and Dean Liddell initially informed him that he would need to consult the college's governing body, a step that would almost certainly have led to his expulsion. For undisclosed reasons, Liddell reversed his decision the following day, allowing Dodgson to remain at the college despite the rules.

Dodgson never achieved the priesthood, a singular distinction among his contemporary senior students. The definitive reasons for Dodgson's rejection of the priesthood remain unconfirmed. Some theories propose that his stammer contributed to his reluctance, stemming from an apprehension of preaching. Wilson cites Dodgson's correspondence, which details challenges in reading lessons and prayers, rather than difficulties with extemporaneous preaching. Nevertheless, Dodgson did preach later in life, despite not being in priest's orders, suggesting that his speech impediment was probably not a primary determinant in his decision. Wilson further highlights that Samuel Wilberforce, the Bishop of Oxford who ordained Dodgson, held strong objections to clergy attending the theatre, a significant interest of Dodgson's. Dodgson also showed interest in less common Christian denominations, admiring F. D. Maurice, and in "alternative" religions such as theosophy. During the early 1860s, Dodgson experienced profound distress from an inexplicable sense of sin and guilt, often recording in his diaries his belief that he was a "vile and worthless" sinner, unfit for the priesthood. This pervasive feeling of unworthiness likely influenced his choice to forgo priestly ordination.

Missing diaries

From Dodgson's thirteen diaries, at least four complete volumes and approximately seven pages of text are unaccounted for. The disappearance of these volumes remains unexplained, while the removal of the pages is attributed to an unidentified individual. While many scholars hypothesize that family members expunged the diary content to safeguard the family's reputation, this assertion lacks definitive proof. With the exception of a single page, the missing diary entries pertain to the period between 1853 and 1863, when Dodgson was between 21 and 31 years of age. During this decade, Dodgson reportedly experienced significant mental and spiritual distress, acknowledging an intense awareness of his own transgressions. Concurrently, he composed a substantial body of love poetry, prompting speculation regarding its autobiographical nature.

Numerous theories have been proposed to account for the absent material. One prevalent theory concerning a specific missing page (dated June 27, 1863) posits that it was removed to obscure a marriage proposal made by Dodgson to the eleven-year-old Alice Liddell on that date. Nevertheless, no corroborating evidence has ever substantiated this claim; conversely, a document discovered by Karoline Leach in the Dodgson family archive in 1996 presents contradictory evidence.

This document is referred to as the "cut pages in diary" record. Philip Dodgson Jacques, Carroll's nephew, stated that he authored this document considerably after Carroll's demise, drawing upon information provided by his aunts, who had destroyed two diary pages, including the entry for June 27, 1863. Jacques himself did not personally view these pages. The summary for June 27 indicates that Mrs. Liddell informed Dodgson of circulating rumors concerning his conduct with the Liddell family's governess, and also regarding his association with "Ina," presumed to be Alice's elder sister, Lorina Liddell. The subsequent estrangement from the Liddell family is presumed to have resulted from these rumors. Lacking corroborating evidence, Leach proposes an alternative interpretation, noting that Lorina was also the name of Alice Liddell's mother. Significantly, the document appears to suggest that Dodgson's rupture with the family was entirely unrelated to Alice. Until a primary source is uncovered, the precise events of June 27, 1863, will remain uncertain; however, a 1930 letter from the younger Lorina Liddell to Alice might offer further clarification. In a report detailing an interview with an early biographer of Dodgson, she stated:

I said his manner became too affectionate to you as you grew older, and that mother spoke to him about it, and that offended him so he ceased coming to . . Mr. D used to take you on his knee . . . I did not say that.

Migraine and epilepsy

In an 1880 diary entry, Dodgson documented his initial experience with migraine with aura, providing a precise description of the "moving fortifications" phenomenon characteristic of the syndrome's aura stage. While there is no definitive evidence to ascertain whether this constituted his inaugural migraine experience per se or if he had previously encountered the more prevalent form of migraine without aura, the latter scenario appears more probable, considering that migraine typically manifests during adolescence or early adulthood. A distinct form of migraine aura, termed Alice in Wonderland syndrome, derives its name from Dodgson's eponymous book and its central character, owing to its manifestation of perceptual distortions resembling the sudden alterations in size depicted in the narrative. This condition is also identified as micropsia and macropsia, a neurological disorder that alters an individual's perception of object size. For instance, an affected individual might perceive a large object, such as a basketball, as being the size of a golf ball. Although some scholars have posited that Dodgson experienced this specific type of aura and incorporated it as an inspiration in his literary endeavors, no supporting evidence substantiates this claim.

Dodgson experienced two episodes involving loss of consciousness. Diagnosed by Dr. Morshead, Dr. Brooks, and Dr. Stedman, these episodes, along with a subsequent one, were classified as "epileptiform" seizures, a diagnosis Dr. Brooks revised from an initial assessment of fainting. While some infer that this condition persisted throughout his life, his diaries offer no corroborating evidence beyond the aforementioned diagnoses of these two specific attacks. Notably, authors such as Sadi Ranson have proposed that Carroll suffered from temporal lobe epilepsy, a condition characterized by altered rather than complete loss of consciousness, with symptoms often mirroring experiences depicted in Alice in Wonderland. Carroll documented at least one instance of complete unconsciousness, awakening with a bloody nose and subsequently reporting a prolonged period of disorientation. This particular attack was also potentially diagnosed as "epileptiform," and Carroll later referenced his "seizures" within the same diary. It is important to note that many contemporary diagnostic procedures were unavailable during the 19th century. Yvonne Hart, a consultant neurologist at the John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, analyzed Dodgson's symptoms. Her conclusion, cited in Jenny Woolf's 2010 work The Mystery of Lewis Carroll, suggests a high probability of migraine and a possibility of epilepsy, though she expressed significant reservations about a definitive epilepsy diagnosis without additional data.

Legacy

Numerous societies globally are dedicated to the appreciation and dissemination of his literary contributions, alongside scholarly inquiry into his biography. The Lewis Carroll Children's Library is situated on Copenhagen Street in Islington, North London. In 1982, a memorial stone honoring him was unveiled by his great-nephew in Poets' Corner, Westminster Abbey. An asteroid, 6984 Lewiscarroll, was discovered in January 1994 and subsequently named in his honor. The Lewis Carroll Centenary Wood, located near his Daresbury birthplace, was inaugurated in 2000.

Given his birth at All Saints' Vicarage, Carroll is commemorated at All Saints' Church, Daresbury, through stained glass windows illustrating characters from Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. The Lewis Carroll Centre, an annex to the church, commenced operations in March 2012. A substantial private collection comprising thousands of Lewis Carroll-related artifacts, including correspondence, photographs, illustrations, and books, was bequeathed to Christ Church, University of Oxford, in 2025.

Works

Literary works

Mathematical works

Other works

References

Bibliography

Digital Collections

Archival Material Collections

This collection encompasses Carroll's correspondence and various drawings, including illustrations for Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking-Glass by Sir John Tenniel, alongside other related documents.
This compilation comprises publications, correspondence, and various other materials authored by or associated with Lewis Carroll, originating from the Cassady Lewis Carroll collection. The collection is subject to ongoing expansion through Dr. Cassady's subsequent donations.
Beyond several loose prints, the majority of the photographs are housed within five personal albums compiled by Carroll during his lifetime, collectively containing over 200 original albumen prints primarily produced by Carroll himself.
This collection features miscellaneous clippings accompanied by a manuscript title-page. Partial contents, likely in Carroll's handwriting, are located on the inside cover and on an inserted separate sheet.

Biographical Information and Scholarship

Çavkanî: Arşîva TORÎma Akademî

About this article

About Lewis Carroll

A short guide to Lewis Carroll's life, books, literary style and influence.

Topic tags

About Lewis Carroll Lewis Carroll biography Lewis Carroll books Lewis Carroll works Lewis Carroll literature Lewis Carroll writing style

Common searches on this topic

  • Who was Lewis Carroll?
  • What books did Lewis Carroll write?
  • What is Lewis Carroll's literary style?
  • Why is Lewis Carroll important?

Category archive

Torima Akademi Neverok: Archive of Literary Works and Authors

Delve into the rich world of literature with our comprehensive collection of articles. Discover biographies of influential authors, analyses of classic and contemporary works, and explorations of literary movements from

Literature Authors Literary History Kurdish Literature Poetry Literary Criticism

Related articles

Home Back to Literature