philosophy

Cynicism (Ancient Greek: κυνισμός) represents a philosophical school of thought from ancient Greece, spanning the Classical, Hellenistic, and Roman Imperial eras. This philosophy posits that humans are rational beings, and the path to happiness and life's purpose lies in attaining virtue through alignment with nature. This alignment is achieved by adhering to one's innate reason, embracing a simple existence, and living without shame or societal constraints. Adherents of this school, known as Cynics (Ancient Greek: Κυνικοί, Latin: Cynici), publicly and derisively repudiated conventional aspirations such as wealth, power, glory, social acceptance, conformity, and material possessions.

Antisthenes, a student of Socrates in the late 5th century BC, is credited as the initial philosopher to articulate these principles. His successor, Diogenes, famously resided in a ceramic vessel on the streets of Athens, pushing Cynicism to its ultimate conclusions through prominent public displays of non-conformity, thereby becoming the quintessential Cynic philosopher. Crates of Thebes followed, renouncing considerable wealth to embrace a life of Cynic austerity in Athens.

Following the 3rd century BC, Cynicism's prominence diminished, yet it underwent a resurgence during the 1st century with the emergence of the Roman Empire. Cynic practitioners were observed soliciting alms and disseminating their philosophy across imperial cities, while analogous ascetic and rhetorical concepts surfaced within early Christian thought. By the 19th century, a focus on the pejorative elements of Cynic philosophy contributed to the contemporary definition of cynicism, denoting a skeptical inclination regarding the genuineness or benevolence of human intentions and conduct.

Etymology of the Term "Cynic"

The appellation cynic originates from the Ancient Greek terms κυνικός (kynikos), signifying 'dog-like', and κύων (kyôn), meaning 'dog' (with the genitive form kynos). An ancient theory posited that Cynics were so named because Antisthenes, the inaugural Cynic, instructed at the Cynosarges gymnasium in Athens, a name translating to "place of the white dog." Nevertheless, it is widely accepted that the term dog was also pejoratively applied to early Cynics, referencing their blatant disregard for societal norms and their choice of street dwelling. Diogenes, notably, embraced the epithet "the Dog," reportedly asserting, "other dogs bite their enemies, I bite my friends to save them." Subsequent Cynics similarly endeavored to reinterpret the term favorably, as elucidated by a later commentator:

The designation of Cynics is attributed to four distinct reasons. Firstly, their lifestyle is characterized by indifference, as they cultivate a disregard for convention, mirroring dogs by eating and engaging in sexual activity publicly, walking barefoot, and sleeping in tubs or at intersections. Secondly, the dog's inherent shamelessness is emulated, with Cynics embracing shamelessness not as a lack of modesty, but as a transcendence of it. Thirdly, the dog's role as a vigilant guardian reflects their commitment to safeguarding the principles of their philosophy. Fourthly, the dog's discerning nature, capable of differentiating between allies and adversaries, parallels their practice of identifying and kindly welcoming individuals suitable for philosophical inquiry, while metaphorically "barking away" those deemed unsuitable.

Philosophical Tenets

Among the Hellenistic philosophies, Cynicism stands out as particularly distinctive. It purported to provide individuals with a pathway to happiness and liberation from suffering during an era marked by instability. While no formal Cynic doctrine ever existed, the core tenets of Cynicism can be succinctly outlined as follows:

• The ultimate objective of life is defined as eudaimonia, coupled with mental clarity or lucidity (ἁτυφια, atuphia)—a state literally meaning "freedom from smoke (τύφος, tuphos)," which symbolized erroneous belief, intellectual vacancy, foolishness, and arrogance.
• Eudaimonia, or the state of human flourishing, is contingent upon self-sufficiency (αὐτάρκεια, autarkeia), mental composure, arete (virtue or excellence), philanthropy, parrhesia (frankness or free speech), and an attitude of indifference towards life's fluctuating circumstances (adiaphora ἁδιαφορία).
• Attaining eudaimonia necessitates living in harmony with Nature, as interpreted through human rationality.
• Arrogance (τύφος) arises from erroneous value judgments, which subsequently engender negative emotional states, artificial desires, and a morally corrupt character.
• Ascetic practices (ἄσκησις, áskēsis) facilitate an individual's progression toward flourishing and intellectual clarity, liberating them from external influences like wealth, fame, and power, which are deemed valueless in the natural order. Instead, Cynics advocated a life characterized by ponos. For them, this concept did not primarily denote physical labor; for instance, Diogenes of Sinope sustained himself through begging rather than manual work. Rather, ponos signified a deliberate embrace of hardship, exemplified by practices such as wearing minimal clothing and enduring winter barefoot.
• Adherents of Cynicism cultivated shamelessness or impudence (Αναιδεια, Anaideia), actively challenging and subverting the societal nomos, which encompasses established laws, customs, and unexamined social conventions.

Consequently, a Cynic disavows personal property and repudiates all conventional societal values, including wealth, renown, authority, and public esteem. A life aligned with nature necessitates only the fundamental requirements for survival, and liberation is achieved by shedding needs derived from social convention. The Cynics revered Heracles as their archetypal hero, embodying the ideal Cynic. Heracles, notably, "was he who brought Cerberus, the hound of Hades, from the underworld," a feat particularly resonant with Diogenes, the "dog-man." Lucian further observed that "Cerberus and Cynic are surely related through the dog."

The Cynic philosophical path mandated continuous rigorous training, encompassing not only the cultivation of sound judgments and mental impressions but also a significant component of physical discipline.

[Diogenes] asserted the existence of two distinct forms of exercise: mental and physical. He contended that physical exercise, during its execution, generated swift and agile mental impressions that significantly aided the cultivation of virtue. However, he maintained that neither form was complete without the other, as the health and vitality essential for virtuous conduct are equally contingent upon both mind and body.

This philosophical stance did not imply a withdrawal from societal engagement. On the contrary, Cynics were expected to reside openly within public view, maintaining complete indifference to any affronts arising from their unconventional conduct. The Cynics are credited with originating the concept of cosmopolitanism; famously, when questioned about his origin, Diogenes declared himself "a citizen of the world, (kosmopolitês)."

The exemplary Cynic was envisioned as an evangelist, serving as humanity's vigilant "watchdog," whose duty was to persistently challenge individuals regarding their erroneous behaviors. Through their lived example and incisive satire, Cynics aimed to uncover and expose the underlying pretensions embedded within everyday conventions. While Cynicism predominantly focused on ethical principles, certain adherents, such as Monimus, also engaged with epistemology, particularly concerning tuphos (τῦφος), articulating skeptical perspectives.

Cynic philosophy exerted substantial influence throughout the Hellenistic period, ultimately serving as a significant precursor to Stoicism. Apollodorus, a Stoic philosopher from the 2nd century BC, famously asserted that "Cynicism is the short path to virtue."

Historical Overview of Cynicism

Classical Greek and Roman Cynics posited virtue as the sole prerequisite for happiness, considering it entirely sufficient for its attainment. Adhering rigorously to this philosophy, they disregarded all pursuits not conducive to the perfection of virtue and the achievement of happiness. This commitment led to the appellation Cynic, derived from the Greek term κύων (meaning "dog"), reflecting their perceived neglect of societal norms, personal hygiene, familial ties, and material wealth, akin to canine behavior. Their objective was liberation from conventional constraints, fostering self-sufficiency, and living strictly in harmony with nature. They repudiated all conventional conceptions of happiness tied to money, power, and fame, striving instead for lives of unadulterated virtue and consequent felicity.

The ancient Cynics actively repudiated conventional social values and critically examined behaviors, such as avarice, which they identified as sources of human suffering. The prominence given to this critical dimension of their doctrine subsequently contributed, during the late 18th and early 19th centuries, to the contemporary understanding of cynicism as "an attitude of scornful or jaded negativity, especially a general distrust of the integrity or professed motives of others." This modern conceptualization of cynicism stands in stark opposition to the ancient philosophical tradition, which underscored "virtue and moral freedom in liberation from desire."

Philosophical Influences

Several philosophical traditions, such as the Pythagoreans, promoted a minimalist lifestyle centuries before the emergence of Cynicism. Early in the 6th century BC, Anacharsis, a Scythian sage, integrated a simple existence with critiques of Greek societal norms, foreshadowing practices that would become characteristic of the Cynics. Notably, accounts of Indian philosophers, referred to as gymnosophists, who embraced rigorous asceticism, may have also contributed to this intellectual climate. The 5th century BC witnessed the Sophists initiating a critical examination of numerous facets of Greek society, including religion, jurisprudence, and morality. Nevertheless, Socrates exerted the most direct influence on the nascent Cynic school. While not an ascetic himself, Socrates articulated a profound appreciation for virtue, an detachment from material wealth, and a marked disregard for conventional public opinion. These specific elements of Socratic philosophy, though peripheral within Plato's broader system, served as the primary impetus for Antisthenes, another of Socrates' disciples.

Symbolism

In antiquity, Cynics were frequently identified by their distinctive attire: an aged cloak and a staff. The cloak referenced Socrates' characteristic dress, while the staff symbolized the club of Heracles. These objects attained such profound symbolic significance for the Cynic way of life that ancient authors criticized individuals who believed merely adopting the Cynic attire would qualify them for the philosophy.

During the societal transition from the Archaic to the Classical period, the general populace progressively discontinued carrying weapons within the poleis. Initially, carrying a sword within urban centers was customary. Subsequently, a shift occurred, first to spears and then to staffs, until the practice of bearing any weapon in the city evolved into an anachronistic and imprudent custom. Consequently, the mere act of carrying a staff acquired a subtle taboo connotation. Contemporary theorists propose that the staff served as a multifaceted symbol: it simultaneously indicated the user's detachment from manual labor, thereby signifying conspicuous leisure, and also carried associations with sport, frequently appearing in hunting and athletic attire. Therefore, it conveyed attributes of activity and martial prowess, rather than merely representing a frail individual's need for support. The staff itself thus communicated the Cynic's freedom, interpretable as an emblem of leisure, yet equally conveyed a message of strength—a virtue abundantly embodied by the Cynic philosopher.

Antisthenes

The historical narrative of Cynicism conventionally commences with Antisthenes (c. 445–365 BC), an elder contemporary of Plato and a direct pupil of Socrates. Despite being approximately 25 years Socrates' junior, Antisthenes emerged as one of his most significant disciples. While subsequent classical authors readily identified him as the progenitor of Cynicism, his philosophical perspectives appear to have been more intricate than the simplified tenets of later, pure Cynicism. Diogenes Laërtius's catalog of works attributed to Antisthenes reveals a predominance of writings on language, dialogue, and literature over those concerning ethics or politics, potentially indicating an evolution in his philosophical focus over time. Undeniably, Antisthenes advocated a life characterized by poverty:

I have enough to eat till my hunger is stayed, to drink till my thirst is sated; to clothe myself as well; and out of doors not [even] Callias there, with all his riches, is more safe than I from shivering; and when I find myself indoors, what warmer shirting do I need than my bare walls?

Diogenes of Sinope

Diogenes (c. 412–323 BC) stands as the preeminent figure in the history of Cynicism. His relocation to Athens was prompted by his flight from Sinope, his native city, following an incident where he and his father, the director of the Sinopean mint, faced legal repercussions for currency falsification. The subsequent proverbial phrase "defacing the currency" aptly encapsulated Diogenes' profound rejection of societal norms. While later accounts suggest Diogenes became a student of Antisthenes, their actual encounter remains unconfirmed. Nevertheless, Diogenes embraced Antisthenes' doctrines and an ascetic lifestyle, characterized by self-sufficiency (autarkeia), rigorous austerity (askēsis), and unreserved shamelessness (anaideia). Numerous anecdotes, though of uncertain veracity, depict his extreme asceticism (e.g., sleeping in a tub), his provocative behavior (e.g., consuming raw meat), and his sharp critiques of conventional society (e.g., "bad people obey their lusts as servants obey their masters"). These narratives collectively illuminate his distinctive character, marked by a profound ethical commitment.

Crates of Thebes

Crates of Thebes (c. 365 – c. 285 BC) represents another pivotal figure in the annals of Cynicism. His significance stems from his decision to relinquish substantial wealth to embrace a life of Cynic destitution in Athens. Although tradition identifies him as a disciple of Diogenes, this association lacks definitive confirmation. Crates wed Hipparchia of Maroneia, who had developed an affection for him, and together they adopted an itinerant, impoverished existence in Athens, where Crates garnered considerable respect. Beyond his unconventional way of life, Crates' enduring renown derives from his role as the mentor to Zeno of Citium, the progenitor of Stoicism. The discernible Cynic elements within early Stoicism, exemplified by Zeno's progressive perspectives on sexual equality articulated in his Republic, are largely attributable to Crates' profound influence.

Other Notable Cynics

The 4th and 3rd centuries BC saw the emergence of numerous other Cynic philosophers, including Onesicritus, who accompanied Alexander the Great on his expedition to India; Monimus, known for his skepticism; Bion of Borysthenes, a moral satirist; Cercidas of Megalopolis, a legislator; and the diatribists Teles and Menippus of Gadara. Nevertheless, the ascent of Stoicism during the 3rd century BC precipitated a decline in Cynicism's prominence as a significant philosophical movement. A resurgence of Cynicism did not occur until the Roman era, specifically in the first century AD.

Cynicism in the Roman Era

Documentation regarding Cynicism during the 2nd and 1st centuries BC is sparse. Cicero (c. 50 BC), despite his keen interest in Greek philosophy, offered minimal commentary on Cynicism, remarking only that "it is to be shunned; for it is opposed to modesty, which is essential for both rectitude and honor." Nevertheless, by the 1st century CE, Cynicism experienced a robust resurgence. The emergence of Imperial Rome, mirroring the earlier Greek subjugation under Philip II and Alexander three centuries prior, likely fostered widespread feelings of disempowerment and disillusionment. This societal climate provided fertile ground for a philosophy emphasizing self-sufficiency and internal contentment to thrive anew. Lucian lamented the pervasive presence of Cynics across the empire, who were often observed on street corners advocating virtue. He noted that "every city is filled with such upstarts, particularly with those who enter the names of Diogenes, Antisthenes, and Crates as their patrons and enlist in the Army of the Dog." Similarly, Aelius Aristides observed their tendency to "frequent the doorways, talking more to the doorkeepers than to the masters, making up for their lowly condition by using impudence." Demetrius emerged as the most prominent Cynic figure of the 1st century CE, earning Seneca's commendation as "a man of consummate wisdom, though he himself denied it, constant to the principles which he professed, of an eloquence worthy to deal with the mightiest subjects." In Rome, Cynicism simultaneously served as a target for satirists and an aspiration for intellectuals. During the 2nd century CE, Lucian, while deriding the Cynic philosopher Peregrinus Proteus, concurrently lauded his own Cynic instructor, Demonax, within a dialogue.

Cynicism eventually became conceptualized as an idealized variant of Stoicism, a perspective that prompted Epictetus to extensively praise the archetypal Cynic in a detailed discourse. Epictetus asserted that the exemplary Cynic "must recognize their divine mission as a messenger from Zeus, tasked with informing humanity about matters of good and evil, thereby revealing their errant path." Regrettably, Epictetus observed that many contemporary Cynics failed to embody this ideal, noting, "consider the current Cynics who behave like dogs waiting at tables, imitating the ancient Cynics in no way except perhaps in flatulence."

In contrast to Stoicism, which experienced a decline as a distinct philosophical school after the 2nd century CE, Cynicism appears to have flourished until the 4th century. Emperor Julian, who reigned from 361 to 363, echoed Epictetus's sentiments by commending the ideal Cynic while simultaneously lamenting the conduct of actual adherents. Sallustius of Emesa, documented in the late 5th century, represents the last Cynic recorded in classical historical accounts. As a disciple of the Neoplatonic philosopher Isidore of Alexandria, Sallustius committed himself to a life characterized by Cynic asceticism.

The Interrelationship Between Cynicism and Christianity

Interpretations of Jesus as a Cynic Figure

Historians have identified parallels between the doctrines espoused by Jesus and those of the Cynics. Certain academics propose that the Q document, a conjectural shared source for the Gospels of Matthew and Luke, exhibits significant resemblances to Cynic teachings. Researchers engaged in the pursuit of the historical Jesus, including Burton L. Mack and John Dominic Crossan from the Jesus Seminar, contend that 1st-century AD Galilee represented an environment where Hellenistic concepts intersected with Jewish intellectual and cultural heritage. Gadara, a city situated merely a day's journey from Nazareth, was particularly recognized as a hub for Cynic philosophy; Mack characterized Jesus as a "rather normal Cynic-type figure." Crossan posited that Jesus more closely resembled a Cynic sage within a Hellenistic Jewish framework than either a Christ destined to atone for sins or a messiah aiming to establish an autonomous Jewish state in Israel. Conversely, other scholars express skepticism regarding a profound Cynic influence on Jesus, attributing greater significance to the Jewish prophetic tradition.

The Impact of Cynicism on Early Christian Thought and Practices

Early Christians potentially adopted numerous ascetic practices from Cynicism and frequently utilized similar rhetorical strategies. Historical accounts indicate that some Cynics faced martyrdom for their outspoken opposition to established authorities. Peregrinus Proteus, a notable Cynic, initially lived as a Christian before embracing Cynicism, while in the 4th century, Maximus of Alexandria, despite being a Christian, earned the appellation "Cynic" due to his austere lifestyle. Christian authors frequently lauded Cynic poverty but condemned their perceived shamelessness; Augustine, for instance, asserted that Cynics had, "in violation of the modest instincts of men, boastfully proclaimed their unclean and shameless opinion, worthy indeed of dogs." Furthermore, Christian ascetic orders, such as the Desert Fathers, exhibited a direct connection to Cynicism, evident in the wandering mendicant monks of the early church whose external appearance and many practices bore strong resemblances to those of earlier Cynics. Leif E. Vaage, a scholar from Emmanuel College, drew comparisons between the shared characteristics of the Q document and Cynic writings, including the Cynic epistles. These epistles encapsulate the wisdom and often polemical ethical principles advocated by Cynics, alongside their emphasis on purity and ascetic disciplines.

In the 2nd century, Justin Martyr engaged in a notable dispute with Crescens the Cynic, who reportedly characterized Christians as atheotatous, meaning "the most godless." This accusation stemmed from the Christians' repudiation of pagan deities and their lack of temples, statues, or sacrificial rituals. Such criticism was prevalent against Christians and persisted through the 4th century.

Notes

Branham, R. Bracht; Goulet-Cazé, Marie-Odile, eds. (2000), The Cynics: The Cynic Movement in Antiquity and Its Legacy, University of California Press, ISBN 978-0-520-21645-7

• Branham, R. Bracht; Goulet-Cazé, Marie-Odile, eds. (2000), The Cynics: The Cynic Movement in Antiquity and Its Legacy, University of California Press, ISBN 978-0-520-21645-7Dudley, R. (1937), A History of Cynicism from Diogenes to the 6th Century A.D., Cambridge University PressKidd, I. (2005), "Cynicism", in Rée, Jonathan; Urmson, J. O. (eds.), The Concise Encyclopedia of Western Philosophy, Routledge, ISBN 978-0-415-32924-8Long, A. A. (1986). Hellenistic Philosophy: Stoics, Epicureans, Sceptics. University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-05808-8. Retrieved on January 16, 2023.Long, A. A. (1996). "The Socratic Tradition: Diogenes, Crates, and Hellenistic Ethics." In R. Bracht Branham and Marie-Odile Goulet-Cazé (Eds.), The Cynics. University of California Press, pp. 28–46. doi:10.1525/9780520921986-003. ISBN 978-0-520-92198-6. Accessed via De Gruyter.Navia, Luis (1996). Classical Cynicism: A Critical Study. Greenwood Press. ISBN 978-0-313-30015-8Prince, Susan (2005). "Socrates, Antisthenes, and the Cynics." In Sara Ahbel-Rappe and Rachana Kamtekar (Eds.), A Companion to Socrates. Blackwell Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4051-0863-8Schofield, Malcolm (1991). The Stoic Idea of the City. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-226-74006-5Primary sources

  Primary sources

  • Socratis et Socraticorum Reliquiae, edited by G. Giannantoni, 4 volumes (Naples, 1990). Volume 2 compiles fragments of the early Cynics, from Antisthenes to Crates.
  • The Cynic Philosophers, edited by R. Dobbin (Penguin, 2012).
  • Diogenes the Cynic: Sayings and Anecdotes: With Other Popular Moralists, edited by R. Hard (Oxford, 2012).
  • Diogenes Laërtius. Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers, Book VI: The Cynics.
  • Dio Chrysostom. Cynic Discourses: Oration 6, Oration 8, Oration 9, Oration 10.
  • Epictetus. Discourse 3.22, On Cynicism.
  • Pseudo-Lucian. The Cynic.
  • Julian the Apostate. 6th Oration – To the Uneducated Cynics.
  • Julian the Apostate. 7th Oration – To the Cynic Heracleios.

  Secondary sources

  • Ian Cutler (2005). Cynicism from Diogenes to Dilbert. McFarland & Co. ISBN 0-7864-2093-6.
  • William D. Desmond (2006). The Greek Praise of Poverty: Origins of Ancient Cynicism. University of Notre Dame Press. ISBN 0-268-02582-7.
  • ———— (2008). Cynics. Ancient Philosophies Series. Acumen Publishing. ISBN 1-84465-129-0.
  • F. Gerald Downing (1992). Cynics and Christian Origins. T. & T. Clark. ISBN 0-567-09613-0.
  • Luis E. Navia (1996). Classical Cynicism: A Critical Study. Greenwood Press. ISBN 0-313-30015-1.
  • Lousa Shea (2009). The Cynic Enlightenment: Diogenes in the Salon. Johns Hopkins University Press.
  • H. C. Baldry. "Zeno's Ideal State." Published in The Journal of Hellenic Studies, Volume 79 (1959), pages 3–15. doi:10.2307/627917.
  • Kathy L. Gaca. "Early Stoic Eros: The Sexual Ethics of Zeno and Chrysippus and their Evaluation of the Greek Erotic Tradition." Published in Apeiron: A Journal for Ancient Philosophy and Science, Volume 33, Number 3 (September 2000), pages 207–238.
  • Cynicism on In Our Time at the BBC
  • Fieser, James; Dowden, Bradley (Eds.). "Cynicism (philosophy)." Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.The Dictionary of the History of Ideas.
  • Herbermann, Charles (Ed.). (1913). "Cynic School of Philosophy". In Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.Source: TORIma Academy Archive